There was this creepypasta fanfic I read years ago before I changed my profile which was about a bunch of the main creepypastas living in a house together and there was a lot of plot. not a reader x __ fic. I think the title was something like “the house” but I don’t remember.
Wattpad used to have this feature where it’d show all your comments and votes on stories to everyone and I deleted any old comments i had on stories to follow an irl. I was the only regular commenter because the story was very underrated (at least to me at the time), and the author and I talked back and forth about the plot.
I wrote this in case anyone stumbles upon it and knows the book/author.