can u tell me what do u mean by constructive criticism?. i know it takes a lot of effort and time to create a book. but they should also know that a book effects a reader not only in outerlevel but psychologically also weather positively or negetively. may be those incidents will not happen to all readers in real life, but for some they do right. all we have asked for a balance of character. i believe a book not only effects our mind but also our thinking process in our society. any type of story should have a hope for those who think they have given up. our request for that author is also the same. justification for each character. why one person was allowed to do but the person has not even given the right to thats all. we have no intention other than that. we respect the author . thats why when so many people ar bringing her personal life, all people unanimously supported her, then why only they are asking for one thing over and over again, becvause we felt the difference clearly at the end of book clearly. thats what we are questioning. other than that we have been perfectly fine with other stories. then why this story only? i hope u are not offended by question. if u did, i am sorry. for those who appreciate the story, they may not have any questions, for those who criticise the story it is too much to ask why the story is what it is, if she could give that, we will just shut up and read not even comment. thats all. writing skills ,? what is there to criticise on her writing? its te storyline we wanted question, thats all