Sam or Dean Girl?

Chapter 1: A well kept-secret

Dean calls out "Y/N are you ready to head out?" from the Impala "Yes" you call back and hurry up and throw your stuff into the back of the Impala and drift off to sleep. Sam hops in the driver seat and they start driving home towards the bunker. Sam looks at dean and says "I'm kind of glad Y/N is with us she keeps us sane I don't know where we would be without her." Dean rolls his eyes and looks out the window but replies with a "Yea, she's a real fire cracker". They both laugh and Dean asks Sam "hey, do you think we can stop and get a hotel for the night? I'm exhausted and sure could use a drink." Sam replies "Sure I'm kind of tired too." They pull up to a Motel the sign read Crossroad Motel. Sam can't help but laugh and say "oh, what the hell". Dean gives Sam a slight smile and hops out of the car, He than grabs the bags out of the backseat while you're still passed out in the back and takes them into the room they rented for the night. Sam walks up to dean and says "Hey I asked the lady up front where the nearest bar is she said it's about a mile up the road, I'm going to ask Y/N if she wants to go with us or not." "Ok" dean replies.

 Dean tries not to get excited he's always had a thing for Y/N but he doesn't want to let her know because he can tell how much Sam likes her, Sometimes Sam tries to act like he doesn't but come on Dean knows everything about his brother and he could definitely tell when he liked a girl. Sam scoots in next to you and gently wakes you up "Hey do you want to go get a few drinks with Dean and I at the bar?" You Shake your head in a yes motion and start to slide out of the back seat when Sam takes your hand and says "If your too tired I can stay with you so you can get some rest" you reply "No Sam it's ok that nap was the perfect amount of sleep but I appreciate it" and you give him a hug and finish getting out of the Impala.

Dean is in the room, He picked up his black backpack and was walking out the door as you and Sam were walking in. He is checking your ass out the whole time when Sam catches him.. Sam gives him a look and Dean replies "What? I'll meet y'all in the car.. Sam hurry up and get ready princess" and you laugh at his comment and sigh.. You Love these men so much they each have their Quirks about them Sam was kind and loving but was also very nerdy in his own sexy way. Dean on the other hand was sarcastic and Cocky but was very playful and not to mention hot as hell. You thought to yourself, Man what is wrong with me.. Neither of them is into me and even if one was how would you choose? You grab your bag and quickly change in the bathroom as soon as you see Sam changing his shirt. Man how did I put up with this for so long it's hard not to stare at their beautiful bodies.

Dean sticks his head in the room come on man what is taking so long this isn't a beauty pageant and you laugh and say "fine ill just wear a band t- shirt and smell like sweat." "Just the way I like it baby" Dean says jokingly. Sam walks out of the room and gets in the car. Dean throw his backpack in the back of the car and is leaning on the car waiting for you to get in as you lock the motel and walk toward the Impala you smile at him and feel weak in the knees as he smiles back and gives you a hug as you approach "hey beautiful, nice of you to finally join us." You hug him harder and reply "Nice of Sam to invite me" and wink at him. Dean snaps back instantly "Hey it was my idea to stop here for the night and have some drinks anyway he just beat me to asking you." You told him that you were just messing around and hopped in the car and Dean drove to the bar.

 Sam walked right in and got a table and ordered two beers for them and a Mikes Harder for you. Your favorite. Dean held the door for you and asked you a question which you didn't know how to answer because you thought it was a joke.. "Do you like Sam? I swear sometimes I see it in your eyes when he talks to you." "No, that's silly Dean" you replied and you walked through the door faster so he didn't see you blush. Sam was sitting at the table looking sexy like always and you walked up behind him and said let's play a drinking game.

So you played the drinking game and you got a little too frisky with dean when he asked if you wanted another drink by grabbing his collar of his shirt "no I want you" Dean said I think Y/N has a little too much to drink don't you think so Sam and whispered in your ear "Be careful sweetheart don't get me started don't want you to regret it in the morning" and kissed your head. You laughed and said "oh believe me I wouldn't regret shit" and got up and started walking to the door and said I'm going to crash in the Impala y'all. Sam followed you out of the bar to make sure you got to the car ok. He said you are being very outgoing tonight try to get some sleep and he sat outside with you while you passed out.

As Sam was outside Dean reached into his backpack to grab something and he found a journal "Son of a bitch I grabbed Y/N bag instead of mine" he took the journal out and flipped to the most recent page in it. He thought to himself if she won't tell me how she feels about Sam ill find out for myself. Feeling brave from the alcohol he began to read. The journal read today's date "god why can't I just pick one and be happy I know one of them could make me such a happy girl, But I can't choose one or the other they are both just so perfect and not to mention sexy... A few seconds ago dean called me beautiful I wish I believed him... We are about to go to the bar to have some drinks maybe I'll make a move on him tonight and just stick with him.. But Sam on the other hand, good lord he's so kind and loving.. Why does my heart want them both...down a few lines it says ". " I fantasize about them all the time just Dean grabbing me and pulling me on top of his hard waiting cock (which is probably fucking huge) and I ride him then Sam walks in and starts kissing me down my spine and kisses and touches me all over.. Oh I have to stop I'm getting too turned on for this and were finally at the bar write more later".

The only words that escape Dean's mouth are "Son of a bitch." Sam says "what?" and surprised dean and he closes the journal right away "is that Y/N journal? "uhm maybe dean replies, Fine yes it is" Sam gives dean a dirty look and asks " Why the fuck are you reading her Journal that's personal" Dean lowers his head because he knows what he did was wrong but if he didn't he wouldn't of ever known how she felt about him but how she also felt about Sammy. Dean looks back up at Sam and says "She loves us both man, That's why she's never came onto us and tonight when I thought she was just getting too over whelmed she was coming on to me and I stopped her.. What the hell is wrong with me?" Sam looking confused "She loves us both? I never saw that coming"

 Dean looks at him and says "She is good at keeping secrets, I think I need to talk to her tell her how I feel Sammy I like her too". Sam looks at him and stands up with a pissed look on his face "Hell no man I like her too you're not going to storm up to her and ruin my chances." "God damn it Sammy read this part in journal she was choosing me" and slides it to him. Sam reads the entry and says "She may have been settling for you but she wants us both Dean, not just you can you ever think about anyone but yourself. She isn't just some quick lay" Dean stands now and gets pissed off "Fuck you Sammy I care about her and I actually want to be with her If I wanted to just fuck her I would of already".

 Sam pushes dean and says "at least give her a chance to choose" dean pushes him back and says "Fine, how the hell are we going to do that just tell her we read her journal that'll sure get her motivated". Sam rolls his eyes and sits down and says "No dumb ass why don't we just lay low till she makes another move". "Dean snaps back quickly with "Hell no dude it took her this long to even do what she did tonight I'm not waiting any longer.. Why don't we just give her what she wants?" as he sits down Sam looks at him with a shocked face "What do you mean Dean like have a Three sum with her? We're not gay and we're brothers that's a little fucked up don't you think?" Dean shakes his head and looks at him and replies again "Bro there will be an amazingly beautiful woman between us and it's what she wants and we both obviously want her so why not give her what she wants and we all have fun and figure out the details along the way?"Sam smirks and gives it a thought and says "Whoever she chooses at the end of this the other brother has to step off deal?" "Deal" Dean says and shakes Sam's hand. Dean and Sam plan out exactly how they are going to do this they are going to sneak Sam into the motel then wake Y/N up and surprise you with Sam being inside the hotel already.