Superman ( An IM5 Fanfic )-Completed-

Chapter 18.

* Faith's POV *

When we got home, all the lights were turned off.

Weird.

"Guys? Hello!" I yelled.

"Maybe they aren't here, lets go upstairs." Cole said while we ran upstairs.

We went into Cole's room, and started to jump on the bed.

"So Faith.... do you hate me still?" He asked.

I thought about it for a bit.

"No.... At least you made an effort more than the rest. So I guess we are cool." I said.

He smiled.

"Faith, I'm gonna go get some food." He said, I just nodded.

He was taking quite awhile.... It doesn't take that long....

I decided to walk out and see what was taking him forever! I walked out and saw he was in front of Will's door?

"Cole what are you doing? I thought you were getting food." I asked

"Listen." He said.

I gave him a weird look, but put my head to the door.

"Whatever. But all I know is that I love Faith the most, so I think she will choose me." Dana said.

"Woah! I love her most!" Gabe said.

"I do! I would do anything for her! She is my love!" Will said.

"Shut up! I love her most! We all know that!" Dalton.

I was looking at Cole, he turned around and looked at me too.

I could see he was in deep thought. What was he thinking?

"Faith... Would you please be my girlfriend?"

Shit.

What do I say!!!

What do I do!

Ummm.... Ummm...

I don't wanna turn him down, but I really do like him.... But what about the rest?

"Faith, please answer!" Cole yelled full of anger. I know he wanted an answer... I just couldn't give him one.

I started to feel water prickle up in my eyes. I was crying. I don't know what to do. I wasn't crying because of what Cole just did, I'm crying because I don't want to hurt them. If I say yes the others would be devastated and probably would never talk to Cole again....

And they just admitted they loved me.

All of them did.

I started to cry even harder.

Cole turned to me with a worried yet surprised look spread across his face.

"Faith, oh my god I'm so sorry, I didn't mean to yell at you. Please forgive me." Cole begged.

Before I can answer, the door swung open revealing 4 boys.

They all knelt down next to me.

"What happened? Who did this to you? Do you need me to kill them with a penguin? Dana asked.

"I'll turn into Batman and capture the person if you want to." Gabe said.

"Do you need me to round up all my vampire friends?" Dalton asked.

"Do you need me to get piano keys and shove it up their-" Will started to say but I cut him off.

"First, do not continue what you were saying Will! Second, thanks guys for helping. Third.... Well um I fell down and hurt my head really really hard, then I kinda hurt my foot." I lied.

"Do you need an ambulance?" Dalton asked.

"I'm not dying! And I'm perfectly fine now. Cole got me ice."I lied.

"Where's the ice?" Gabe asked raising an eyebrow.

"Guys I'm hungry!" I said skipping the question.

I saw Gabe roll his eyes since I avoided his question.

"Yeah me to!"Dana yelled.

"Well I guess me and Faith will stay here while you guys get food!" Will said.

"No I should stay with her." Gabe said pushing Will away.

"I think I should stay with her!" Dalton yelled.

"Hey! Me and her are the hungriest!" Dana yelled.

"Guys! Let me stay with her! I need to talk to her about some things!" Cole protested.

"Shut up! And I still hate all you guys, besides Cole! So all of you idiots get me food!" I yelled, scaring them a bit.

"Yes, Ma'am." They all chorused.

* 5 Minutes Later *

They finally left.

Now....

I need to think of what I'm going to say to Cole.

Yes

Or

No.

Lets make a list of Pros & Cons. I got a piece of paper, and a pen and wrote:

Pros and Cons on wether or not I should date Cole!

Pros:

1) I get to be with Cole.

2) I do like him... Alot.

3) I still get to be close with the rest.

Cons:

1) The boys would be so miserable.

2) they all... Love me.

3) They would never speak to Cole.

4) I would be breaking their band apart.

5) They would probably be mad at me.

I wrote all of these down.

Looks like Cons wins....

I guess I have to say no to Cole...

How am I going to do this!