Superman ( An IM5 Fanfic )-Completed-

Chapter 19.

* Faith's POV *

Since the boys were still out picking up food, I have to figure out how i will let down Cole.

What are some ways i could let him down......

Call him and tell him?NO.

Just walk up to him and say no?NO

Tell him i like the others to making me sound like a bitch?NO

Bring him out for a bit and talk about it?YES!

I knew exactly what i would do!

I would bring him to the park, then i KNOW he would ask about it, then i would tell him why i said no without sounding mean!

* 10 Minutes Later *

The door opened revealing 5 boys.

"Faith we got In-N-Out!" Dana and Will yelled.

I went over to the kitchen picking up a burger and walking up to my room.

"Faith! Come down and eat! Talk to us please!" Gabe yelled.

Eh. What else do i have to lose?

I got up and walked back downstairs, walked into the kitchen and sat down at the table.

"Hi Faith." Dalton said taking the seat next to me.

"What do you want? Don't you want to wish you never met me again?" I spat out coldly.

"Faith.. i didnt mean to say that. Please forgive me."Dalton pleaded.

"No. You cant just say you wished you never met a person then expect that person to forgive you so easily."I said.

Tear. A tear rolled down his cheek as i said that. I felt bad..... he has to accept what he had done.

Thank god the rest of the boys are eating in the living room.

"Faith....... i know this is a bad time but....... will you be my-" Dalton started to say but got cut off by Dana running in saying " Guys come here! We are on TV!"

We got up and went into the living room.

"girlfriend" Dalton mumbled as he sat down, thinking no one heard him. I did.

Wait! Dalton was about to ask me to be his..... Girlfriend! Shit! How am i suppose to let Cole down..... then Dalton.

I have to let down Cole first.... Then Dalton....

I have to change my plan.....

I got up and looked at Cole mouthing " Go upstairs now" He nodded and did as i told.

He met me in the hallway.

"I want an answer." Cole said.

"Look... i really like you Cole, but..." I started.

"But what Faith?" Cole questioned.

In the corner of my eyes i could see the rest of the boys spying on ut.

"Faith!" Cole yelled.

"Look i like you, i really do, but i alsoliketheotherboysandifisayyestoyoutheywouldbesad." I said super fast so he won't understand

"Faith slow down." He said.

I looked in the back of me and saw the boys trying to hide behind the wall.

"I like the boys too....if i say yes to being your girlfriend dont you think that would hurt them? I hope you understand...." I said letting a tear fall from my eye.

"Faith.... please. I love you. I love you way more than the rest of them. I promise to never hurt you. And im sure they will forget about it. I love you Faith." He said taking my hand.

"Faith dont-" Will started to say.

I turned around and i saw the 4 boys putting their hands over Will's mouth.

"Faith dont say yes please." Gabe and Dana said, letting a few tears fall from their eyes.

"I love you Faith. Dont say yes." Will said, walking over to me.

"Faith... dont do it.I love you. I need you." Dalton said, with tears running out of his beautiful eyes.

"Faith, your going to have to choose one of us. I hope it is me though.."Cole said whispering the last part.

I looked at these 5 boys one by one.

"G-guys.... i just cant choose right now. I need time."I said.

"H-how much time?"Dana and Cole asked in between quiet sobs.

"Time." I said then pushed past them locking my self into my room/guest room.

What was i going to do?

Who will i pick?