Bloody Knives /Jeff The Killer X Reader\ {Completed}

Nothing to Title This

I wake up in Jeff's bed. He must have put me to bed after I fell asleep in his embrace. I go downstairs. I eat some leftover cheesecake. Jeff walks up to me.
"Me and Smile Dog are going to the park. Wanna come?"
"Yeah."
When we get to the park, it's like we become little kids. We slide on the baby slides and we play with Smile Dog. At around late afternoon, we start to walk back.
"Umm, can I ask you a question."
"Shoot."
"Would you... I mean, would you like to become a creepypasta? So we could be together?"
I jump into his arms. "Yes!"
He picks me up and spins me. "Slender and I will make the arrangements."
Then, Jane appears out of the woods. "You never were this romantic with me!"
"FFS Jane, I killed your parents and then you want to date me! Then, you got overly attached and was always snooping around my kills, questioning if I was covering my tracks. It's over Jane. Leave us alone."
"But.. I still love you!" She burst into racking sobs.
Jeff takes me by the hand and leads me home. When we walk in, Jeff goes and talks to Slendy. I drop onto the couch. BEN is already sitting there.
"Can I braid your hair?" He asks.
"Sure I guess."
He braids an elaborate braid in my hair. "How did you learn to do this?"
"When Jeff sleeps, I braid his hair. It pisses him off."
I laugh. Jeff comes up and inspects my braid. "I think I wore it better." He says.

~Later that night~
I put on my short blue dress. I apply eyeliner and mascara. And I cry till it runs everywhere. I slip on my sandals. I stare into the mirror at my future creepypasta face. I glide down the stairs into Jeff's arms.
"Hey." He whispers.
"'Ello gov'nor." I whisper. He laughs. He grabs my hand and pulls me outside. My bike, all washed and repainted, sits next to his. I jump on. Jeff leads me through the woods. It seems like hours till we finally reach the house, of the victim. Jeff opens the window. He pulls out his knife.
"Here, take it. Use it for good luck."
I kiss him slightly on his cheek. Then, he hoists me into the window. A teenage blond lays in her bed. I grip the knife tightly. I turn and I see Jeff taking a video of this to send to Slendy so he can post my creepypasta story. I place my hand on her mouth. She wakes with a muffled scream. I hold up Jeff's knife.
"Sweet dreams."
Then, I plunge the knife into her chest. Her eyes fade away. I carve tears into her face. I wipe the knife on her t-shirt. I jump into Jeff's arms. It was so intense.
"I watched her life fade."
He presses me close to him. "The first kill is hardest. It will always be the one you regret."
I bury my face into his jacket. He whispers to me. "I love you."
"I love you, too."

~back to the mansion~
We lean our bikes against the side of the mansion. Jeff opens the door to the pitch black house. "After you."
I step into the doorway. Suddenly, the lights flash on. "SURPRISE!"
I see everyone smiling. Presents are placed in the corner. BEN wheels in a white tiered cake with strawberries and red dye on it like blood.
BEN stammers,"I.. I..made the cake. With Slender's help of course." Slender waves in the background with his pink apron on. Jeff says," This is a party to celebrate you becoming a creepypasta."
I sit on the couch taking everything in. Jeff excuses himself to the bathroom. I hug everyone. Even the mortal girl that Toby's with, even though I've never seen her. I am happy that Toby found someone.
Jeff returns with a rectangular blue box wrapped with white ribbon.
"Here."
I slowly slip off the ribbon and open the box. A thin, delicate knife lays inside. On the handle is a ring. I slip it off with tears welling in my eyes. I read the inscription on the beautiful diamond ring.
"I love you, too."