Which Guy is for Me?

Reunion

Just as promised, Jean makes you a nice, warm cup of coffee.
    "Sugar?"
    "No it's alright, the way you made it is just perfect" you smile, looking into his deep, brown eyes.
    "Not that you need to tell me, but why were you sitting outside. In the dark. While it's raining. Crying your eyes out?"
You completely forgot why you were crying when you saw Jean earlier. But it all came rushing back to you...Eren and Mikasa. You start to feel tears swell from your eyes again.
     "Hey (Y/N), it's alright. You can tell me what happened."
     "God, I hate this. It's been over what, 6 years? And our reunion is me crying and you comforting me."
He smiled warmly.
You look down at your soaking wet shoes. You keep sniffing thinking about the thought of your boyfriend and your best friend.
     "Well. I guess I owe it to you." You put the coffee down. "I don't really think you knew, but Eren and I were dating for almost 6 years" you say while choking back on tears.
     "Yeah, I know, (Y/N). I'm not stupid you know. Everyone knows you guys are dating, youre everyones dream couple."
You half-laugh. "Not anymore that's for sure"
He shoots you a confused look.
     "What I mean is....Well....God I feel so stupid saying this out loud."
Jean comes behind you, giving you a huge hug like he used to when you were kids.
      "It's alright, no need to just spit it ou-"
      "Eren cheated on me."
Jeans eyes widen. He suddenly stops hugging you, instead coming around to face you. He grabs another chair, turning it backwards so he can sit and see your face.
      "What the fuck did you just say? Yeager did what?"
You hide your face in your sleeves. "Don't make me repeat it. It's embarrassing enough. Ughhhh I just don't get why he did it. And with my bestfriend too!"
Now his mouth drops.
"Huh?!...you can't even call her a bestfriend anymore. She a hoe. For da STREETS".
You both laugh.
"Yeah I don't know, I didn't think I did anything to Mikasa to deserve this. I don't know, sucks I lost both my bestfriends in a day".
You look over, seeing Jean in absolute shock.
"D-Did you say Mikasa? Like Mikasa Ackerman??"
"Yeah, why you know her?"
He coughs. Shifting in his chair visibly uncomfortable.
"Guess you could say that. She's my ex"
"Wha-"
"Shut up I regret it. It was only for like a month until I realized she was a crazy bitch. She wasn't good in bed either"
Your eyes widen. "JEAN" you hit him.
"Ouch...what its true. She didn't know how to suc-"
"Oh my god shut up...TMI" you laugh, feeling a little better about the situation.
He smiles softly at you, "there's that smile", he moves the hair out of your face.
You smile back at him.
As stupid as that was, it made me feel better. "At least I know i'm better in bed" You wink.
"Huh really?? Care to show me (Y/N)" Jean smirks.
"You wish" you look at the clock. "Oh jeez it's getting kind of late. I'm really glad we got to talk Jean-Boy, I missed this. I don't know why we ever stopped talking".
"Me either. Here hand me your phone before you leave". You do as he says. He enters his name into your phone. You look at it...Contact Name: Mr. Sexy Man. You look up at him. "Oh my god. You cannot be serious." He laughs, "What, i'm not lying". You roll your eyes, "i'm changing this to Horse Face".
"DONT YOU DARE-"
You giggle, running out of his dorm, "too late Jean-Boy, it's already in my phone. I can't change it".
You hear his distant voice "you're gonna regret this (Y/N)!". You just laugh, please, this is the best thing that's happened all day.

As soon as you walk into your dorm, you see your roomate Sasha. "Hey (Y/N), you smell like coffee, did you bring any food with you??" She says with a drooling face.
"I'm sorry sasha not today"
She pouts. "Fine...Hey, where Mikasa? She usually comes here at this time"
You go over to your bed and gently sit down on it. "Well actually you see-"
"Hold that thought (Y/N), it's mikasa...Hey whats up. Yeah she's here, why. Oh ok, I see, alright see you later" She smiles. "So what were you saying??"
You're uncomfortable. "Oh. What'd Mikasa say, is she coming over?"
"Nah, she said you two got in an argument. Told me to come over where she is in a hour or so...but it's not like you guys to not make up right away, whatd you do" she says laughing.
You start crying.
"Oh my god, (Y/N), I was joking!! What happened between you two?"
"H-Her and Eren" sniffling through the words, "I found them in bed together today".
She's obviously surprised. Mouth all the way on the floor. "What. Isn't today your guy's 6 year???"
"Yeah."
She gets up, pacing the room. "That fucking bitch. And you swear that you didn't mistake it??"
"Nope. My boyfriend and bestfriend were fucking"
She grabs her phone and storms out of the dorm. "SASHA, WHERE ARE YOU GOING?"
You hear her yell back, "IM GOING OUTSIDE. THESE WORDS IM ABOUT TO SAY ARE NOT LADY LIKE". She closes the door behind her.

You run after her, carefully hiding behind a pillar. You overhear the conversation.
"Oh don't give me that shit Mikasa....No are you serious why would I need to hear your side, (Y/N) has done everything for you, what did she do to deserve this. There's a million guys after you and you decide to go for HER man...No shut the fuck up, don't bother coming back here. I'm pulling your shit out of here you can go live with your boy toy. Fuck off, we never want to see you again" She violently ends the phone call, walking over to the entrance when she sees you.
"O-Oh...you heard that huh?" She giggles embarrassed.
You go in and give her a huge hug. "I love you, you know"
"I know, I know. Now go get me some food, all that yelling made me hungry".
"You got it". You both walk into the dining hall and give her your card. You sit down, waiting for sasha to come back—god knows when she will. She gets food from every station.
All of a sudden you get a notification.
*Horse Face* 1 Message
Hmm, you go ahead and think, "Wonder what that's about?"