Finn:
Since he is allergic to cats, you couldn't get a kitty, so you decided on this adorable beagle, and named him/her Cookie.
Sam:
You both wanted a cat, so when you went to the store, you got two.
Puck:
Puck wanted a snake or a spider but you shut that down before it could even happen, so you decided on a big dog.
Artie:
You went to the shelter, and couldn't decide on just one, so when you got home, Artie wasn't expecting one cat, let alone two!
Mike:
You wanted an enerjetic dog so you could teach him how to do cute dance moves.
YOU ARE READING
Glee Boy Preferences
FanfictionI LOVE reading Glee Preferences, but I feel like there isn't enough of them.. so now I am writing my own! I am not using the girls in this one, but I can write another one for the girls if you guys want me to. Let me know if there are any characters...