Creepypasta Boyfriend Scenarios

Second Meet part 1

Slenderman

The first encounter was a little weird, even if you were scared, you couldn't help but cry out your feelings to him. When you were finished, he wiped your tears. He wanted to stay with you but not now, the forest was getting darker so he told you to come back in mid-afternoon. It was near that time now and you were afraid but he seemed so sincere and kind you just had to get back to him. You mustered up the courage to go to him and found a pleasant surprise. Instead of the faceless man you saw a male, near your height with mesmerizing jet black eyes. The signature black suit and red tie was a dead give-away to what he was before.

"Slender? Is that you?" You asked nervously.

He nodded and took you to a lake where picnic items were laid out in front of you. You gasped and looked at him in disbelief. He merely shrugged and told you to enjoy. You did. As time went by you two laughed and had fun, the all familiar emotion brewing slowly, but surely in your chest.

Jeff the Killer

You slept with a bat. That's it. He scared the crap out of you when he said that but at the same time intrigued. You two chatted away and soon the sun rise marking the end of your talk. He promised to return the same night and this time you wanted revenge for scaring you so you slept with a bat. So when he came you smacked him in the family jewels. He screamed and you laughed.

"Karma's a bitch!"

"Fuck you!"

You guys spent the night chasing and swearing at each other. Feeling childish and immature, you two were really meant to be.

BEN Drowned

You parents lectured you as you groggily ate your breakfast. BEN stayed the whole night so you stayed up the whole night as well. You ignored them because today, they were going away so you had the whole house to yourself for four days and you planned to spend those days with BEN and your games. As soon as they were satisfied you would get arrested they left and on cue, BEN came out of your T.V. with a bunch of junk food in his arms.

"Ay Y/N! Ready for the weekend?"

You grinned and brought out some drinks. The whole you and he bonded over video games and food. Yet you couldn't help but feel a different thing yet you just couldn't figure out what.

Eyeless Jack

The next time was at night, again. But it was merely by fate that you ran into him. You had learned your lesson so this time you were wearing a long sleeved shirt and sweater with jeans. He whistled, seeing the major change.

"Finally learned your lesson?" He said with a chuckle.

You rolled your eyes at him and playfully hit him. Since it was dark you two decided to go to a park. Your dog, (d/n), wouldn't top barking at him but as soon as he got comfortable he would never go far from him. You were a bit jealous though at the fact your dog now loved him more than you but he seem to be happy so you didn't say anything. Trying to break the silence you started up a conversation.

"So what's your name?" You asked while trying not to lose sight of (d/n)

He went silent before answering you.

"Jack, my names Jack."

You nodded then pointed at his mask.

"What's with the mask?"

"Um..... It's complicated..." He said nervously.

You wanted to know more but saw it was a sore subject for him so you didn't ask. Instead you grabbed a stick and threw it. (d/n) barked in joy and ran after it. You guys spent the evening playing with (d/n).