You love her.Prompt- an argument between three avengers, one will be left behind and two will be happy but who is the question.
Dinner was uncomfortable long pauses of silence, few words exchanged and very little eye contact. "Wanda..." you sighed, the conversation that awaited was inevitable so there wasn't much use putting off. "Wanda, please." You repeated but still she stayed silent. "what's wrong, please just talk to me." You asked, you knew exactly what was wrong, so why you asked who knows.
You did in fact do something, something that would hurt Wanda in ways you yourself would experience too later. "you love her." She says, its all she says, and I guess that doesn't make much sense, but it does. You see Wanda is the girl of your dreams she makes your life picture perfect except last night that picture shattered into a thousand pieces.
You kissed Natasha. Or she kissed you, its all really a blur but the technicalities aren't what matter, Wanda saw, and you hurt her and that's all that matters. "I- I don't Wanda that not what happened." You protested but the blank stare on Wanda's face was enough to tell you, your excuses didn't matter.
"don't- don't you dare sit there and tell me it meant nothing and its not what it looks like." She pushed herself out from the table and stood up pacing up and down, her hands covering her mouth in a prayer position. "Wanda" you cried, there was no stopping it now you'd already broke her you deserved to watch her suffer.
"I would care. I'd listen. I'd even get over it if I didn't see the two of you every day, the way you look at her. All it takes is her smile and you stop in a trance and you forget I exist." She sighed. "you know that's not true Wanda, I love you." you say, your voice cracking through streams of tears.
"I've watched you for a while now, I had suspicions and ignored what I could see right in front of me but last night I walked past her room and you were there, your hands in her hair. She kissed you like you were the only girl in the world, and you liked it." The way her voice shook when she spoke was enough to kill you there and then, you heart in a pit in the bottom of your stomach drowning in worry.
You'd hardly had a second to process what was going on when she walked in. Talk of the devil, and she'll appear. "Please, don't throw this all a way." You beg, but the sight of Natasha seems to only make everything worse.
Watching Wanda break down like this hurt you, of course it did, but to reiterate you deserve to watch her suffer. "What's going on why are you crying?" Natasha drops by your side as you sit in the chair hugging your knees to your chest. She stood back up looking at Wanda and she knew; she knew exactly what was going on.
Wanda's face said it all its as if the words were engraved in her head. "I should go" Natasha said, clearing her throat. "Don't leave, don't you want to know what she has to say." Wanda laughed sarcastically though her tears.
"Wanda, I love you please stop." These words seemed so much harder to say with Natasha standing right beside you. Because even if those words were the truth, they most definitely weren't the whole truth. "you lover her?" this time these words came from Natasha she looked hurt and angry but mostly she looked broken.
Wanda had been right Natasha did make you feel something, amazing things but so had she and picking between the two was brutal. "Natasha wait..." god why cant you make up your mind, the longer you wait the worse you are making it, you thought. There faces waiting in anticipation.
"I just don't know anything anymore... leave please both of you, I'm sorry but I won't sit here and pick. Its wrong." You spat out, it was too late for morals and rights and wrongs, you'd already made too many mistakes.
YOU ARE READING
The Sweetest Seduction- Natasha x Wanda x Reader one shots
FanfictionOne shots Reader x Natasha Reader x Wanda and Reader x Wanda x Natasha open for requests :) i'm trying to make sure the reader has as little description as possible but if you'd like me to do more specific reader x character i can do Contact me on...