So Many Choices... I don't even know!

31 1 0
                                    

When I woke up, the first thing I remembered was BEN coming in, and me falling asleep in his arms. The next thing I remembered was Stephen showing me what he was going to do. I really need to talk to Slenderman, but I don't feel like moving. BEN started stirring behind me, so I turned towards him. I have to keep him safe, no matter what. I have to hurt him, so that he'll leave. I got up before he could wake up, I grabbed my crutches, and limped out of the door. "What are you doing? It looks like you're running away." I turned around to find Stephen. The look on his face was sheer enjoyment, then I noticed who's door he came out of. Lavender's. I should've known if we brought him here, that he would cause trouble. Jeff is going to kill him, wait, maybe that's what I want. "Hey Jeff?!" I yelled. He came up the stairs and noticed Lavender first, then Stephen. He looked like he was going to explode. Okay, I didn't want Stephen to die. So I grabbed Jeff's arm and pulled him into my room. BEN was still asleep, so we sat at my desk. "Jeff, I have a question." "Okay." "Do you love her?" He was silent for a while, "No." I looked at him in disbelief. I thought he was going to say yes. "What? When did you start feeling like this?" "When we got lost in the forest and you laughed. I realized then, that I want you back. No, I need you back." I didn't have a clue what to say. "I told you not to tell her!" BEN shouted from behind me. I turned to find him sitting up in the middle of my bed. His hair was sticking up everywhere, and his hat was missing. I had never seen him without his hat, he was adorable! Seriously, what is wrong with me today? "Listen, I need to talk to Slenderman." I said as I got up and ran to the door. I shouldv'e stayed there to make sure they didn't kill each other. I knocked on Slenderman's door, but he didn't answer. "He left a little while ago." I heard a sad voice behind me say. When I turned around, it was Jane. "What are you still doing alive?" I asked. "You can't kill a proxy. We're immortal." she said, smartly. I just rolled my eyes and walked by her. I got halfway to my room when I heard slams and thumps. I ran to my room to find Jeff sitting on top of BEN, holding a knife over his head. "Don't you dare!" I yelled. The last thing I saw was both of them running towards me. Then it was all black. I left again, now I have to kill. But I don't want to.

--------------------------------------------------------------

The next chapter is split between Molly and Raighn's point of views. Hopefully you guys like it. I'm sharing with my friend Blood Luna <3 Bananas!!!!!

~Angel

Meeting Love in the Creepypasta HouseWhere stories live. Discover now