Say Pretty Please

Chapter 12

Chapter 12

Cat didn't look back at Jade as she left the bathroom. She took Robbie's hand and led him down the hall to where she knew Tori's room was. She stepped inside turned on the light and sat down on the bed with Robbie. He was looking around the room curiously and she could tell it was his first time in Tori's room. She was sure the other girl wouldn't mind if she used it for a bit. She fiddled with her fingers as she watched him.

"It's nice in here." He said with a weak smile as he ran his hands down the front of his pants before looking over to Cat. His face fell at the expression on her face. "What's wrong?" He asked as he reached over to take her hand. She allowed him, looking down at their joined hands.

"I have to tell you something." She whispered the same words she had awhile ago. He nodded his head and waited for her to continue but she didn't really know where to start. She took in a deep breath. "Okay well I guess I'll start with the relationship between me and Jade." She whispered and looked up at him. He looked slightly confused at the mention of Jade but nodded his head for her to continue anyways. "Well before you and I started dating, me and her were...a little more than just friends. More than a little more..." She shrugged her shoulders because that was a pretty nice way of putting it.

They were silent and she watched as Robbie tried to understand what she had just said but he looked more confused then ever. "You and Jade-Wait what?" He chuckled with a shake of his head and looked back to her. She took in a deep breath. "I mean I don't get it." He looked to the door as if he expected Jade to step in and explain it to him.

"We were... I guess what people calls...friends with benefits." He stared at her in disbelief. 

"Wh-what? Does that mean...? You and Jade used to...?" Robbie asked incredulous and Cat just nodded her head. "What? Why? I mean, we never noticed anything when did it started and how?" 

"Huh, an year or so ago, and it's a long story..." she said, he slowly nodded his head still looking confused and slightly hurt. She felt the tears come to her eyes because this was the hard part. "We never did anything when she was with Beck and when I started dating you though. B-but before I-I... we... few minutes ago, down in the bathroom Jade and I...we..." She trailed off giving him a pleading look to understand so she wouldn't have to say it out loud. It only took a split second for him to understand this time.

"Oh my God! I can't believe this..." He shot up from the bed, yanking his hand away from her. He turned his back to her as if just the sight of her disgust him. He ran his fingers through his curly hair. She bit her lip as she watched him fighting back the tears that wanted to spill over. She never wanted to hurt him. "Jesus Cat..." he turned to look at her, his expression a mixture of hurt and anger. "You cheated on me with Jade!?" He shouted.

"It was an accident!" She cried as she stood up from the bed as well. 

"An accident?! Are you kidding me Cat? How could it be an accident? You two had sex! What, do you want me to believe you just tripped and fell on Jade or something? You said it yourself that you were sleeping with her before me so you obviously wanted it to happen!" Robbie yelled at her and Cat winced at his hard words. 

"Please Robbie, believe me when I say I'm sorry... I really, really care about you. I never meant to hurt you and I'm so, so sorry." She shook her head as she covered her mouth trying to stop herself from sobbing. Robbie stared at her, his eyes slightly wide as his thoughts raced.

"This is her fault." He suddenly said as he began to pace the room and now it was Cat's turn to look confused. "She always wants to ruin something good if it doesn't benefit her! She-She tricked you into becoming friends with benefits so she could always have this hold on you and use it however she wanted! S-She used you! That's what she did! This is her fault!" He yelled as he turned to look at her, his eyes wild, nodding his head at his own words. "Don't worry cupcake. I won't let her get away with taking advantage of you like this." He said as he stepped in front of her and put his hands on her shoulders. "We're going to be okay." He tried to smile but she slowly shook her head.