Being Jack J's Sister

Chapter 17

-Matthew's interrogation-
Matthew's POV
The cop sat me down in an interrogation room with a small table and two chairs. We had mini microphones and there was a huge mirror obviously where people watch the interrogation.

"Matthew when was the last time you saw Caitlyn Johnson?" He asked. "Well it was the day before the day she disappeared." I told him. "Did anything happen that day." he asked. "She told us she was dating Taylor." I told him shrugging.

"Did that make you angry I heard you were dating her but she broke up with you because you cheated on her." He told me watching my every move. "Ya I admit I was upset but not enough to kidnap her." I said defensively.

"And why should I believe that, is it because your a good hearted man, no obviously not when you cheated on Caitlyn." "You have motive, you were jealous of Taylor and Caitlyn so you got revenge." he said like it made perfect sense.

I'm angry now. I slammed my hand on the table and shouted, "No that's not what happened I love Caitlyn enough to let her go and be happy, yea I admit I cheated on her and I'm not proud of it!" He just shrugged at my outburst.

I breathed in and calmed down a little bit. "Besides I have an alibi." I told him. "What?" He asked. "I went home with Cameron Dallas and Nash Grier we then went bowling at Nathan's Bowling Center and out to eat at John's fish and sticks all you have to do is check." I said proudly. He looked at me then spoke. "Oh I will." he told me.

I nodded. "That's all Mr.Espinosa don't think about going anywhere you're still a suspect." he said. I lied through my teeth in that interview I know exactly where and why Cat has gone but I will get caught too so I'm keeping my mouth shut.

Cat's POV
"It's too bad Cat I didn't want it to be this way." Gary taunted. We are still in my "room" and he is upset because I don't like him. He walked over to me and forcefully kissed me. I didn't kiss back and I tried to push him away.

It was useless he may not be heavy and I may be strong but it was like he was determined to stay and kiss me. No matter how hard I tried he wouldn't budge. I hit him in frustration. He winced and let go of me. "Oh princess why must you be so hard to get." he said.

"I'm not your princess!" I snapped. He smiled as I turned red from anger. "Come on Gary we need to go!" Jake yelled. "Go where?" I asked Gary.

"Oh sweat heart you're coming too can't get rid of us that easy, but since you have nothing to pack we will come get you when were ready." he told me. I sat in confusion. "We will explain in the car." he said before walking out.

Great we are moving out. That means a new white boring room with just a bed and a blanket. I hope it doesn't down grade. I can't live like this. Someone please come and find me. I miss Taylor and Jack and all the others.

I would much rather be eggy and with a water gun fighting my "brothers" as I think of them. Then be stuck with kidnappers. What if I never get found? What if I die in a stupid white room!

I sat in the room and thought of happier times. When the boys and I had a food fight because of something Taylor said to Nash. The time I went on a date with Taylor and we rolled around in the grass and then out next date was when he asked me to be his girlfriend.

I really do miss those boys. They all have impacted my life good and bad. I heard a knock on the door and the click of the lock. Pete came in being unfriendly as usual. I smiled at him just to see his reaction. He glared at me and waved for me to go.

"Come on doll we ain't got all day." Pete said holding his luggage. I got off the bed and grabbed the plastic bag with some outfits in it. All they gave me was a black sweatshirt, jeans, a grey shirt, a white shirt, and I had Taylor's sweatshirt and shirt I wore the day they took me and jeans.

Right now I'm wearing a 'bad day' shirt that they had given to me yesterday for "being good" I feel like a dog. A mistreated dog. Anyways I also had my black beanie of course they gave me some undergarments and I take a shower too so it's not all that bad.

I grabbed my bag and headed out the door next to Pete. He put his arm around me I didn't mind I like Pete he's hot. But I know I know I have a boyfriend that I love to death just saying though he really is.

Like the day they took me, I was crammed in the middle with Jake and Gary sat beside me, Flint drove, and Pete was in the passenger seat. "Is this your order or something?" I asked breaking the quietness.

"Ya I guess so." Flint said. "Flint you're a nerd, no offense, how did you get stuck in all this?" I asked him. "Well you see they threatened me and unlike you I obeyed and became one of them." He said proud.

The car we were in was a red truck it was old and the paint was rusty. The time blinked on and off on the radio which probably didn't work. The seats are black leather and are in comfy.

"So where are we going to be staying now?" I asked. "Do you ever just shut up?" Jake asked. "No." I said innocently. He rolled his eyes. "We are going about 30 miles out in a shed looking house." Gary said.

I had so many more questions but kept them to myself. Jake looked ready to push me out the car which would have been better but I'm staring to enjoy being with them. Jake is like that mean older brother that deep down inside somewhere he truly loves you.

Flint's the cute nerd who's in it to be cool. Gary is your typical brothers best friend who falls in love with the sister. Lastly Pete is the cutie who thinks he's cooler than all of them but sticks with them. That's how they treat me and each other.

Jake picks on me and thinks I'm annoying sure, but I see him look out for me and every time I'm around him I feel safe. Pete too. Jake is the typical older brother who in public is too cool for his sis but loves her so much. Sure they abuse me sometimes but that's on bad days. I sound crazy but what can ya do.

Jake's POV
I love Cat not in the way to where I wanna date her but no I think if her as an annoying yet cool little sister. But I wouldn't tell any of the guys they would think I've gone soft.

She's cool and unlike any other girl. Her boyfriend and brother and friends are lucky to have her. I wish I wasn't who I am and I could have met her differently I would have been her best friend, her brother, but I messed that all up.

What I love about Cat is she doesn't fear us she treats us like how Matthew said she treated his and her friends. She's really awesome.

Yet annoying and can't stop talking she loves to have a conversation unlike us we like quite and to be in our own minds. I hate the way we treat her I just have anger issues but I'm trying to be better, I don't want us to scare her.

Cat's POV
The ride consisted of Pete hitting Flint every few seconds and Jake looked out the window lost in thought he does that a lot. Gary just went on his phone and would occasionally look at me.

It reminded me of being with the boys and I got homesick. I love seeing them fight and just mess with each other. It shows me they are so much more than bad boys they're kids lost and trying to be cool. Pete smacked Flint's arm as he tried to make a left turn.

"Pete I swear stop!" Flint whined. "Yea Pete your hurting him!" Jake teased. "All of you shut up, Pete hands to yourself and Flint try not to kill us." I said. I was once again reminded of the boys and how I was like their mom.

This was much more like a Peter Pan situation these boys were truly in desperate need of a mother. And like Wendy I knowing I should go home decided to stay just for a bit. I smiled at them I'm beginning to really love them. Love your kidnappers?! Yep!

I rested my head on Jake's shoulder and fell asleep. He thought I was asleep but I heard him whisper, "Sweet dreams Cat I love you, I'm sorry I promise I'm working on helping you, you're safe with me." I smiled and went to sleep as he gently held me. I felt so safe and warm.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Hey guys! Wow Cat is starting to enjoy her kidnappers😱 What will happen next! Only I know😆 Ok guys I hope your enjoying the story please keep voting for it and keep reading! If you want to be one of the boys girlfriends you still have a chance! Bye love ya😘✌️