Fairy Tail: One Shots ~Edited~

Fire and Ice (Natsu x Reader x Gray)

You are in love with both Natsu and Gray. But knowing the two of them you know they would never be able to actually get along for each other let alone you. So you try to get them with Lucy and Juvia but you don't know what they actually think, until now. 

Contains sex scenes

Ever since you were kids, you have always been close with Natsu and Gray. People say it's because you are a Dragon Slayer that makes you get along with Natsu. They also say it's because you wield ice magic that makes you get along with Gray. Whenever you were hungry you would ask Gray to give you some of his ice to munch on. Nice and smooth on the throat. Natsu would work with you on your Dragon Slaying skills.

As you got older you developed strong feelings for both males. You loved Natsu for his goofy personality and his determination to save his friends in dire situations. But on the other hand, you loved Gray for his cool demeanor and the way he cares for his family while trying to act cool. It was cute. But you know that with those two, you would have to choose one over the other but you can't bring yourself to do so. So you stayed silent. Never speak your true emotions to them.

You have thought about a poly relationship with them but knowing them, even if they did like you back, they would never agree to share you equally. The relationship would become toxic so quickly, it was scary. So to avoid that at all costs, you try to get Gray with Juvia and Natsu with Lucy. It made the most sense, and you would go on without either one of the males you love.

One day at the guild, on a very hot summer day in Magnolia, you are at the bar eating a chocolate and vanilla swirl ice cream. Unbeknownst to you, Natsu and Gray we're watching you after getting face planted to the ground by a Scarlet haired mage. The two of them looked at you with blushes dusting their cheeks as they watched you eat and lick the sweet treat. Your tongue laps around the top of the swirl ice cream and takes some of the cream into your mouth. Natsu and Gray look at you with lust slowly clouding their vision.

"Is it just me or is (Your Name) really seductive today," asked Gray to the cherry blossom haired teen. Natsu nods his head slowly but very distinctly. "She is so cute and sexy at the same time. How is that possible," asked Natsu. Gray answers with an 'I don't know' and continues to watch you eat and lick the ice cream. Both males took a moment to look at what you were wearing. You were wearing a black tank top with blue jean shorts that are pretty short but long enough to cover your parts. You also wore a white overcoat with ocean blue lining on the rims of the coat. You were also wearing black thigh high boots that had a small heel to it but mostly flat. Right above the boot on your left thigh was your ocean blue guild mark. Both males couldn't help but feel their pants grow tighter the more they looked at you.

After many minutes later you finished the ice cream in your hand as well as the cone that held your sweet treat. You turned to Mirajane giving her some jewels to pay for the ice cream. "Thanks Mirajane. I'm gonna go see if there are any missions I can go on." "No problem (Y/N)!"

You step off the stool you were sitting at and you walk up to the request board. You look and skim through the many jobs on the board. After about two minutes you find a job that requests that you go to Mt. Hakobe to retrieve 5lbs of a special ice that can boost up magic power and help people who are sick. You take the request off and you walk back over to the white haired female who is drying a beer mug. You state that you will take this request and then set off to the job. While you were walking away, Natsu and Gray looked at each other and then back at your walking figure. They turn back to one another and smirk to one another, an idea that will for sure make all parties happy.

~~~

By the end of the night, you returned to the client with the 5lbs of the special ice for the scientist who is trying to find a cure to cancer. You admired the scientist and wished him the best of luck before returning to Magnolia. When you arrived in Magnolia the streets were lit up by the street lights that made the town look as alive as it is during the day time. You wave to the ones who wave to you. You smiled sweetly as you made your way to Fairy Hills. When you reach your apartment you take your overcoat off and lay down sighing very heavily. 'That was a hike, jeez.' You lay in your bed for a little longer until you sat up to take your long boots off your legs. You look at the foot board where your sleep shorts are and change your shorts. You then take your tank top and bra off and put on the long sleeve shirt also hanging on the footboard.