Yellow eyes - Foxy X Reader

Chapter 13

-Foxy's P.O.V.-

I feel bad for (y/n), ye know... but I'm alright with Crystal. I be happy. I be a pirate, I be free. That be all it matters!

"So, you want to go somewhere else? A private place?" Crystal asks, holding me hand.

"Aye. I think Pirate Cove be a good place to start" I giggle.

"Let's go then, Captain" she jokes. We walk 'til we arrive to our place.

"Ye shine like a crystal, and ye be beautiful like a rose. I suppose that be the reason why ye have that sweet name" I flirt. She grabs me face and kisses me. Her lips are soft like her voice. I love her. But I don't know if I love more (y/n) or Crystal... I grab her waist and pull her closer to me. She slightly moans. "Ye like it, don't ya?"

"Y-yeah..." she whispers, and inserts her tongue inside me mouth. We play for a while with our tongues, 'til I remember (y/n) again. I love her too... I don't know if I'm doing the correct thing. We finally separate, gasping and panting. "It's pretty late. Let's go to sleep"

"Ye be right. Let's sleep" I say, laying on the ground. She hugs me, and I hug her back.

"I love you Foxy" she whispers. I doubt a little 'bout my feelings, but I respond.

"I love ye too" I say and we finally fall asleep.

I have a nightmare, a horrible nightmare. I dream of (y/n) when she be just a little girl. She be sitting on me lap, as always. I be joking 'bout Bonnie, and then she got angry.

"Foxy! You're bad. Bonnie is the best!!" she yelled. I growl: he be flirting with me girl all the time. I hated him. Then, Crystal appeared behind me. And she told me that, if I hated me girl 'cause she liked Bonnie, I should kill her. And that be it: I bit her head with me mouth full of sharp teeth. She screamed and cried, but I didn't mind. She be one little brat, she deserved it. She fell to the ground, a pool of blood under her. I laughed and enjoyed watching that. But then, she spoke.

"You did... this.... you're....a....monster.....you trusted....Crystal.....she's.....bad....." and as she finished her last word, she died.

I wake up screaming loudly. Crystal, who be next to me, screams too as she covers her ears. I pant and sigh.

"F*cking nightmares......." I whisper. I turn around and see Crystal, scared. Poor lass... I grab her hand. "Ye be alright?"

"Y-yeah... Y-you scared m-me...."

"I be sorry. Nightmares make me scream..." I apologize.

"Don't worry. Let's go eat something"

"I have some food here" I say as I find a pizza in Pirate Cove.

"Good! Let's eat" When we be done eating, I see some blood coming out of Crystal's ear.

"Ye have blood in your left ear, lass!" I gasp. Then, I understand everything: she be deaf of the left ear, and all 'cause of me scream. "Did I... do that...?"

"I'm sorry... I didn't want you to know... I don't want you to feel guilty..." she explains, but it's too late. I can't be with someone I hurt so much.

"Crystal... it be better if we be just best friends... I don't wanna hurt you anymore, and besides, last night I be thinking and... I think I still love (y/n)" I say. Her eyes be full of tears. I hug her. "I be sorry... I be so sorry... Ye will find someone better than me..."

-Time skip, Reader's P.O.V.-

I spent all night talking and crying with Bonnie. He seems to understand my pain, and he's the only one that tries to cheer me up. Foxy is a bastard. I hate him. But I still feel something for him and I can't stop thinking about his yellow eyes and his wide smile...

"Good morning" Bonnie says, noticing that I'm awake.

"Good morning Bonnie"

"Did you hear that scream?" he asks.

"What scream?" I'm confused. I didn't hear any scream.

"It sounded not too far from here. Let's see what happened" he says as he grabs my arm and helps me get up. "It sounded like Foxy. When he has nightmares, he screams"

"He deserves it" I add. Bonnie just sighs and walks down the hall next to me. We find Foxy and Crystal in Pirate Cove. I sigh and look away. I try not to cry, but it's hard.

"What happened?"

"I just had 'nother nightmare. Don't ye worry" Foxy says. I don't know if he's looking at me, and I don't care. I hear him sigh and get up. Then, I feel a pair of arms around my waist, and I see they're Foxy's. I growl and try to walk away, but he won't let me go. "(y/n)... I be sorry..." I gasp.

"You're sorry?! You just f*cking cheated on me, and you're just SORRY?!?! I HATE YOU!!! I yell, pulling him away. His eyes are full of tears, just like my own.

"I... I didn't know what happened... p-please, f-forgive me! I swear, t-this won't happen a-again!!"

"I can't trust you. Besides, Bonnie really cares for me, not like you!" I shout.

"I...I actually have something to add..." Bonnie interrupts. We all look at him. "I love Chica... so... you don't have to be jealous, Foxy... she's just my best friend, that's all!"

"WHAT?!" we all scream.

"Yeah... (y/n) explained me everything Foxy... I'm sorry. I didn't know I was causing so much trouble..." Bonnie apologizes, looking down. We all go and hug him.

"Don't worry Bonnie, it's okay" I say. "But, there's still a question. Why, Foxy? Why did you go with Crystal? Why when I fainted you were not there with me, by my side?"

"Ye see... in the party, I be with Crystal, chatting. Bonnie be the only one who noticed ye fainted, so he took care of ye 'til ye be awake and alright. *sob* I be jealous, and I be sorry. *sob* I thought that ye would be *sob* better with Bonnie than with me, so I left. I felt *sob* guilty, I felt like a monster..." Foxy cries. I kiss him.

"It's okay... it could've been Freddy or Lucky or Chica the one to notice my fainting. It's not your fault. You were just enjoying the party, as everyone else. But... don't do this again, okay? I suffered a lot..."

"I love ye lass... I hope ye forgive me..." Foxy whispers as he hugs me.

"I love you too... if you promise you won't do this again, I'll forgive you"

"I promise. I promise I won't do this stupid thing again. Besides, I hurt Crystal, and I hurt ye. I can't be more sad..."

"I'm sorry too... I should've thought before flirting with Foxy" Crystal adds.

"It's okay, but don't do this again. Please" I say, with eyes full of tears.

"I promise" she ends.