All Is Fair In Love and War

Flogging A Dead Horse

Natsu, being as dense as ever, didn't know what the hell was going on. He flickered his eyes between the blonde and the silverett. "Wait... what's going on?" Natsu said legitimately confused.

Everyone practically sweat dropped. "You're so dense." Gray had his hand on his face. "Lucy and Lisanna both like you." He said, basically spoon-feeding Natsu the answer.

"At least Juvia doesn't have to worry about Lucy or Lisanna going for Gray." She nods. Everyone glances at her, in the most confused way possible. Gray wanted to disappear on the spot.

"So... more girls like me than Gray?" Natsu smiles.

"This isn't a contest you dumbass!" Gray kicks Natsu off his chair.

"Well it is for them." Mira said between sobs. Her sister was getting in the way of her ship, but she didn't want her to get hurt either!

Wendy felt uncomfortable in all this tension, so she devised a plan to stop this. "Why don't we just ask Mr. Natsu who he likes better?" She said, cutting the silence. Lucy and Lisanna nodded in agreement.

"Alright Natsu, which girl do you like better?" Erza said, coming up behind Natsu and clamping her hand on his shoulder.

Natsu stared at the two girls for what seemed like forever, trying to think of who's better. 'Lucy's pretty cute. He has an awesome smile, and she's a good fighter... she can have a temper though. And Lisanna is sweet and I've known her since we were kids, but she's been gone for two years and I feel like I don't know her as well...' Natsu thought to himself.

"I think I Like..."

CLIFFHANGER! Comment who you think he likes better. Next chapter will mostly be a sass battle between the girls, but i hope you like it! Later Minna!