Kristy Thomas:
Who asked: She asked you.
How did it happen: Both of you were playing soccer (football, for my British English loves), and had sat down, tired. Kristy laughed at something you'd said, and both of you were simply happy in each other's company. She looked at you, while you observed everybody around. "Y/n, will you go out with me?" She asked, being straightforward as usual. Taken aback, you faltered for a moment, however you regained yourself and replied with a very enthusiastic 'yes'.
---
Mary-Anne Spier:
Who asked: You asked her
How did it happen: Both of you were having a sleepover, and you decided to put the movie 'Lady and the Tramp'. As the movie commenced you said, "Honestly, Roman Holiday aside, this is the best love story ever." Mary-Anne laughed at your choice of reference and replied, "I couldn't agree more. Roman Holiday is a more...advanced love, I guess." You turned onto your side to look at her and asked, "Simple love is honestly the best, isn't it?" She looked back at you and nodded, "I absolutely agree." Being straightforward, you asked her, "So, if simple love meant you'd go out with a girl if she asked you in a cordial enough fashion, would you say yes?" Taken aback, Mary-Anne stuttered out a 'yes'. "And if that girl was me?" You added. "Absolutely yes, then!" The other girl had a sudden surge of confidence which made you almost jump up and down in joy.
---
Stacey McGill:
Who asked: She asked you
How did it happen: She was babysitting your younger brothers with you, and while the youngest, Roger, was in the bathroom she was very straightforward with it and asked you out with the classic, "Will you go out with me?" You were a little shocked, but nevertheless replied with a big smile, "Yes."
---
Claudia Kishi:
Who asked: She asked you
How did it happen: "Stay absolutely still, Claudia." You said. You were doing a watercolour of her and it had to be absolutely perfect. She was sitting as your model in front of your bedroom window. This was an art project, where you had to depict one person in three different ways of your choice. "You know, this would be more romantic if I had a rose in my hand." She said, barely moving her lips. "Yeah? Well you can make it romantic in the next one." You laughed. "Now shush and continue the dreamy stare you were doing." She smirked to herself and looked out, only to speak again, "It would be easier to capture your romantic piece if you went out with me." You smiled and blushed as you replied, "Sure. You could've been more straightforward about it, though." Before looking back at your painting, leaving her absolutely dumbfounded.
---
Dawn Schafer:
Who asked: You asked her
How did it happen: You two were laying on your bed, staring at the glow-in-the-dark stars on your ceiling, discussing house energies. "I mean, a blue energy is kind of meh." You replied, "So my house kind of has a blue energy with all the negativity buzzing around." Dawn thought for a moment, and replied, "Well, yellow energies are the best. They're so upbeat!" You frowned and scoffed, "Ew no, yellow energy is too peppy. But purple, on the other hand is just...damn. Imagine the amount of psychic energy you'll find." Dawn shook her head, "Red energy is romantic, and I absolutely love those houses." You flipped onto your side and asked, "You've been to a red energy house?" She nodded, "Yeah." You thought for a moment and said, "Well, my room has a red aura anyway, so maybe that's a sign which means that you'll go out with me." Dawn laughed and said, "Not as subtle as I thought you were, L/n, but I like it. Yeah, I'll go out with you."
---
Jessi Ramsey:
Who asked: She asked you
How did it happen: You were with your mom, who was congratulating you on how well you played the piano for Jessi's recital. She noticed that the ballet dancer was coming over and winked at your gay-panicking ass. "Good luck," she whispered, before walking off to meet the teacher. "You were absolutely amazing." Said Jessi with a smile. "I wasn't even visible on stage," You mumbled. "The applause was for you." Jessi pondered for a moment and said, "Tell you what. Maybe your spirits will be lifted if I ask you this." You looked at her inquisitively, "What?" She took a deep breath and blurted, "Will you go out with me, Y/n L/n?" You covered your blushing face with your hands and muttered a 'yes' through your fingers as Jessi laughed and hugged you.
---
Mallory Pike:
Who asked: You asked her
How did it happen: During class, you slipped her a note, inside of which you had written a simple statement, 'Mallory, will you go on a date with me?' You weren't a very subtle person by nature, so your reaction wasn't subtle when she looked at you and nodded a 'yes'. Ripping up the note was a very quick task as the teacher came up to you, however.
---
YOU ARE READING
The Baby Sitter's Club Imagines and Preferences
FanfictionPreferences and Imagines for the following: • Kristy Thomas (Sophie Grace) • Stacey McGill (Shay Rudolph) • Mary-Anne Spier (Malia Baker) • Dawn Schafer: (Xochitl Gomez) • Claudia Kishi (Momona Tamada) • Jessi Ramsey (Anais Lee) • Mallory Pike (Viv...
