Dangerous Daddy

Chapter 31

*For anyone that read this story before, I clearly cut out the Sam scene. I hope this is better." 

"Natalie, I want you to pay close attention to everything I'm about to do. All the pain she's about to feel is the result of your bad choices." Cooper made a show of waving the scalpel around in his hand while he spoke.

"Pease- don't hurt her." Natalie spoke through tears.

"But I have to, Angel. You see, the things I want to do to you would break you too badly, and I can't have that just yet. So instead I will take your punishment out on Marta here." Cooper grinned at Natalie, loving the sight of her tear-soaked face. "Don't be too upset, Sweetheart. Be thankful it's not you, besides she really looks the part."

For the first time since the crying woman was dragged into the room by Sam, Natalie was finally taking a good look at her. They looked very similar, Marta being less attractive of course. Natalie couldn't believe what she was seeing, Cooper had chosen this woman to torture, in her place, solely because they looked alike.

"That's right, you two could be sisters. If I don't look too closely it's almost like I'm punishing you. It's a win-win for everyone!"

Natalie was too stunned to say anything. It wasn't fair and it didn't make any sense to her. 'I'm right here! Just do it to me instead!' She mentally screamed, too afraid to speak aloud. She knew if Cooper would do this then surely he would make their punishments worse if she upset him. She had to tread lightly.

Cooper saw the look of resignation in Natalies eyes and knew it was time to begin. He had purposely waited for her to work things out on her own. He wanted her to really feel the gravity of the situation that she had gotten herself into.

"Alright, first things first. The rules. You will watch everything I do and hopefully learn from this to make sure it doesn't happen again. You will not speak unless I give you permission and you will answer me when I ask you a question. Lastly, you will do everything I tell you to or I will just have to keep bringing people down here until you do." Cooper addressed Natalie. "But you can cry all you want, Angel. You know I love it when you do." He added the last part when he saw her trying to hold back her sobs.

After saying all he had to say, Cooper turned to Marta and slowly drug the knife along her clothed body as he walked around the table to get to the other side. He didn't push hard enough to cut any material, but that didn't stop the woman from crying out and trying to wiggle free.

"Since this is your punishment, you have some choices to make. You will get to choose what I do, but I know that it will be hard for you to do that so I'm going to give you this." He reached into his pocket and pulled out a quarter, tossing it into the cage beside Natalie. "If you're having a hard time then you can use this. Do you understand?"

Natalie picked the coin up and looked at it. She didn't understand anything that Cooper was talking about, if she had the choice then she would say no one gets hurt. Although she suspected that she wasn't allowed to choose that option.

"For example, I'm going to cut the clothes off her, and you have to choose top or bottom." Cooper closely studied Natalie's face as he carefully spoke every word. He could see that she was overwhelmed by her sudden participation in the punishment.

"What? I can't-" Natalie couldn't believe what Cooper was saying.

"Now now, Natalie. I'm going easy on you by giving you that coin to help you choose, but if you're going to be difficult then I'll take it away."

Natalie was torn, she wanted to save the poor girl who should not even be in this horrible room. The innocent woman didn't deserve this. But who knows what Cooper would do if she didn't play along.