9

52 5 4
                                    

Dedicated to: Damonlover81 BurnedNMiami ShannonCataldi Pugsbunny88 NikkiKay88

Rachel watched her sister walk out of the choir room to find Skylar so she and him could spend the rest of the day together. She felt sad for her sister. She was angry that her dads and Millie kept Marley away from her and kept her a secret. Rachel knew she had to protect Marley. and protect her from Jane's comments. She didn't want Marley to get worst.

Rachel walked out of the choir room to her drama class that she was teaching, with her mind racing and was all over the place after what Marley had told her. She was in a world of her own when she bumped into the Biology teacher Caitlin Snow. 

Rachel looked up at Caitlin and said

"I'm sorry Caitlin. I have a lot on my mind. I wasn't watching where I was going. And before you ask no it's nothing to do with Sebby and I." Rachel never really liked Caitlin for the reason she would constantly flirt with Sebastian when he's there to help her with the glee club at times. Rachel is well aware of Caitlin's crush on Sebastian.

Caitlin thinks Sebastian deserves better than Rachel. And she constantly makes sure Rachel knows

"Oh well. He'll get tired of you Berry. You know he will." Rachel rolled her eyes and continued on her way. Rachel knew that Caitlin was only after Sebastian because she could never have Barry who has always loved Iris. Rachel has always thought Barry is definitely with his soulmate Iris. 

She walked into the drama room and saw Jane waiting for her. Jane smiled at Rachel sweetly.

 "What do you want Jane?" Jane gently spoke

"I just want to say I'm sorry for how i disrespected you and everyone in glee." Rachel looked at her and said

"I thank you for your apology Jane. But I'm not pairing you with Skylar in drama today. you worked with him last week. And besides he's with Marley showing her around the school, since it's still her first official day today." Jane couldn't believe what she was hearing. 

She couldn't believe that Skylar was once again with the new girl. Jane folded her arms and walked to her seat for the lesson to begin.

Later that day when the school day had ended. Rachel got in from being at Dalton and was met with yelling. She walked inside the apartment, and there Sebastian was standing across her fathers and Finn.

Rachel couldn't believe it. She walked over to them, and stood by Sebastian taking his hand.

"What are you three doing here?" Before Hiram and Leroy could speak, Finn spoke

"Here for you of course Rachel. For you to be with me again. We were good together. Unlike you and preppy. We all know your co worker Caitlin wants him." Rachel couldn't believe what she was hearing. She stood in front of Sebastian and said

"No Finn. We weren't. You cheated on me with Quinn, and kept comparing me to her." At that revelation, Hiram and Leroy were disgusted with Finn for hurting their daughter. Hiram looked at Rachel and said

"Leroy and I aren't here for you. But we are here for Marley. As her mum Millie is worried about her and wants her home." Rachel shook her head

"No. She's not going home to a mum that kept her from me and kept her for herself, and not going back with two people who lied to me, and kept her from me too. and kept us from each other." Leroy sighed and said

"She's still a minor Rachel." Rachel was defeated and said

"I know she is. But you three kept us from each other, you kept my sister from me and lied to me for years and Millie lied to Marley for years. How can we trust you?" They were all silent, and Finn once again broke the silence

"Wait Marley's your sister? I was her glee director back at McKinley" Rachel nodded her head, and in that instance Finn felt and pang of guilt and regret for kissing Marley, and secretly dating her for that term after finding out Jake cheated on her. They broke up due to the age differences and Finn still being in love with Rachel and Quinn both.

As the awkward silence happened the door had opened, and it was Marley and Skylar. Marley walked in behind Skylar, and saw Finn, with who she assumes are her dads. Marley hoped Finn didn't say anything about that one term in McKinley after Jake had cheated. Finn was the one that went after her. She was still a virgin but she and Finn did other stuff that she knew if it came out Finn would get in trouble, and it was only so she could be a bit more experienced for Jake even though she is asexual.

"Finn, what are you doing here?" Finn looked at Marley, and he now saw the resemblance between Rachel and Marley. Marley stared at him waiting for him to answer. She now knew what he was there for,

"I'm not going back to McKinley, or the glee club there. You are an awful glee teacher. You never did told off Kitty for bullying me and giving me an eating disorder and on top of that you paired me with Santana, who by the way me worst and didn't get me the help, and made the entire thing about her and Quinn and slapped Quinn. So please stop just trying to get me to comeback, don't think I don't know that you're getting Unique to convince me, or even your cousin Ryder to do so." They were all shocked at what Marley had said. Particularly Rachel who spoke 

"You let my sister get bullied to an eating disorder and didn't do anything, and you paired her with Santana who bullied me all throughout highschool and slept with you because you were desperate to lose your virginity as you didn't listen to my I didn't want you and I said no." Finn didn't say anything at all. Hiram and Leroy were disgusted with Finn. They were now looking at Sebastian in a new light and maybe  just maybe approved of him for their oldest daughter. Hiram looked at Finn

"Get out of our sight Hudson." Finn stayed put and Leroy said

"Sebastian will you do the honours." Sebastian smirked and said

"Gladly." Sebastian grabbed Finn's arm and escorted him out of his, Rachel's and Marley's place.

Hiram looked at Rachel and said

"I'll talk to Millie. chances are she didn't help your sister properly either, and if she says anything I'll bring up how she kept her from us all." Rachel softly spoke

"Thank you dad. If you and daddy want to speak to Marley it's up to her." Leroy gave a small smile 

"Of course, and Star, we like Sebastian for you. We're sorry we judged him too harshly. The one we should have been judging and hating is Finn which we do now." Sebastian smiled widely at Leroy and said

"Thank you, and I won't ever hurt Rachel. She's my life and my everything and I support her with everything and every role too." Leroy and Hiram were pleased and started a deep conversation with Sebastian.

As Marley watched on, she now fears that an aspect of her past will come back to haunt her. Skylar looked at Marley concerned

"You okay Marls?" Marley gave a small smile to Skylar

"Yeah I'm okay." Rachel watched Marley the entire time when Finn was there. She suspected that something happened more than what Marley is letting on.


Note: I know Marley is asexual in this story and I know i wrote in this chapter that she and Finn did some stuff. Asexual means lack of sexual attraction to others. Certain asexuals may participate in sexual activity out of curiosity which is how I portray Marley as in this story. She wanted to do so out of curiosity and to have some experience for Jake, and also if she's really really really comfortable in doing stuff like that.

You've reached the end of published parts.

⏰ Last updated: Nov 11, 2023 ⏰

Add this story to your Library to get notified about new parts!

I'm your sister Where stories live. Discover now