This wasn't the first V-Tale theory that I wrote, but it's the first one I wanted to share. Enjoy!
What this theory discusses: Are the V-Tale roleplays set in the past?
Evidence:
Johnny Toast was made into a werewolf recently ("SCARY WEREWOLVES!! - Gmod Werewolf Horror Mod (Garry's Mod)"; May 1st, 2015.)
Oogie Boogie made Ghost send him a real letter ("snail mail"), which took (Ghost said) 3 months, so we can assume Toast has been a werewolf for a while now.
Ghost says (in "FUNNY OOGIE BOOGIE! - Gmod Nightmare Before Christmas Mod (Garry's Mod)") that the last time he took Toast to a social gathering the "Bite Of '87" (Five Nights At Freddy's) happened.
The "Bite Of '87" happened in 1987 (obviously), so this could mean that the Johnnys went back in time (Ghost is a Timelord with a TARDIS; see "RUNNING FROM THE POLICE!! - Gmod Apartment Raid Map" for proof) to the Fazbear establishment, possibly to investigate for a case?
Or do these role-plays take place in the past?
This could explain why some of the characters (save for the Acachallas, as they come back from the dead, so they could be immortal, but that's a theory for another time *bu-dum-tiss* ... no? I'll stop...) say that they were there for events they couldn't possibly be there for (as long as they're normal humans, which I'll go over later.)
Though this could just be an effect of Johnny Ghost having a TARDIS and Papa Acachalla's ambition (possibly wanting money, so he and his group [Maxwell Acachalla, Princeton Quagmire, Jose ×4, etc.] went back in time so they could rob a bank, in which Maxwell dies, contributing to the storyline [which I will also go over later])
P.S. - I'm writing this on my phone, so please don't blame me for any mistakes/typos. Autocorrect can be annoying, ask anyone who's ever written a story on a computer or device.
I will add more evidence to support these theories as I go along, and if you find any, feel free to message me (Please no spam or hate.) Thanks for reading!
