Taurus - BEN drowned ♉️
Libra - Bloody painter ♎️
Scorpio - Clockwork ♏️
Pisces - EJ ♓️
Aquarius - Hoodie ♒️
Virgo - Jane the killer ♍️
Gemini - Jeff the killer ♊️
Capricorn - Lazari ♑️
Sagittarius - Homicidal Liu ♐️
Pisces - LJ ♓️
Sagittarius - Masky ♐️
Scorpio - Nina the killer ♏️
Aries - Sally ♈️
Gemini - Slenderman ♊️
Taurus - Ticci Toby ♉️
Yeah idk some of their birthdays so i might not have gotten them all anyway i randomly had this idea so here ya go
