Ben x Jeff one shots (Creepypasta)

First time (smut)

(Pretty short)
Warnings: Smut obviously.
In this chapter: Toys, praise, semi-public sex, and possibly other things. They also don't live in the mansion in this one.

Ben's POV:
I'm currently gripping Jeff's arm as hard as I can. He has the vibrator in me. We've never actually done it with each other. We've teased each other a lot with toys or something but never actually had sex. Today might be the day though. He's been teasing me all day and said he'll reward me if I can keep quiet. My legs are shaking and Jeff just stands there smirking at me.

Jeff: What? Can't handle it anymore~?
Ben: I can handle it. I-it's f-f—

He turns it up even more and I feel it hitting my sweet spot and almost let a noise escape.

Ben: I-it's f-fine..I c-can ha-handle it.
Jeff: Can you now? Okay we'll keep going for a few moments then. Continue to be a good boy for just a little longer~.
Ben: I'll b-be a g-good boy.

He takes my hand and we continue to walk through the mall. I see him smirk and then we walk into Spencer's. My face turns red as he leads me to the back of the store where all the toys are. We get more vibrators, a cock ring, rope and ribbon, and a ball gag. As we're checking out he turns it on the highest setting since we're about to leave. I almost fall to the ground but manage to keep every noise in.

Jeff: Be careful love.
Ben: S-sorry.
Jeff: Don't be sorry it's okay.
Ben: Okay.

I see the cashier give us a look and chuckles to himself. The cashier is obviously gay and understands what's happening. I tighten my grip on him. The vibrations are pounding into me. I breathe heavily as they continue. The cashier gives us our bag and we walk out of the store. I let out a sigh.

Ben: Please? Are we going home? Please please please...~
Jeff: Yes we're going home darling. Keep behaving though.

I need him so badly. We've never done anything like this but I want to so badly. I've never longed for something so badly before. We walk out of the mall and I stop for a moment. Walking makes the vibrations even more intense if that was even possible. I put my hand over my mouth and pant for a second. I get up though and continue to walk with Jeff. We finally get to our car and start driving home. Once I buckle up I let out a breathe I didn't know I was holding. I shift around and still desperately try to hold in noises.

Jeff: It's okay my dear you can let them out now.
Ben: f-fuck. Oh my god please. P-please! I want you t-to fuck me. I g-give you my c-consent. I n-need you to f-fuck me. P-please~
Jeff: What a good boy you've been~

I'm panting like I'll never breathe again after this. I throw my head back as I feel Jeff playing with the settings and then he suddenly turns them off. I finally get a moment to breathe. Our house is still a bit away. I look at him and he grabs the vibrating dildo from the Spencer's bag. He turns it on without putting it in me and I see how it can thrust and vibrate at the same time. I'm not going to walk for a week after this. I slowly take the other vibrator out and put the new one in. I let a moan escape as I feel the new size. Jeff immediately turns it on. I grip the arm rests as hard as I can. It's so much more intense and it's only on the low setting.

Jeff: If you think that's big just you wait dear~
Ben: F-fuck holy s-shit. T-turn it h-higher..p-please! 
Jeff: Alright since you've been a good boy~
Ben: A-AH..F-fuck...f-fuck...oh my g-god...

I feel Jeff turn it up another level and I rock back trying to get more. I feel him turn it up once again and I slam my head against the headrest. I've never felt so good like this before. I grab Jeff's free hand and squeeze it.