25th Annual Putnam County Spelling Bee Preferences (x Fem!! Reader)

Who says I love you first

Olive ~ she does. You two were having a sleepover at her house one weekend. It was 2:56 am and you were both wide awake. You guys were making out at the time and she pulls away, grinning at you. "I love you." She says, smiling at you. "I love you too, Olly," you reply, kissing the tip of her nose.

Marcy ~ You do. You and Marcy were sitting at lunch with the other spellers. Marcy had been unusually quiet today. You got up, pulling her aside. "You ok, Mar?" You ask, squeezing her hand gently. "I love you, Y/n," she says, hugging you. "I love you too, genius," you say, hugging her back.

Logan ~ You do. You two were sitting on the swings at the playground. She was swinging and as she went to jump off, her finger got nicked by the chain holding up the swings. You get off your swing and walk over to Logan. "You ok, baby?" You ask, taking her hand and examining her finger. "Yea I think so," she says, smiling. "I love you, Logan," you say, smiling. "I love you too, babe," she says, smiling back.

Leaf ~ he does. You and Leaf were laying on your bed, cuddling. You had your head resting on his chest and he was playing with your hair. "I love you pretty girl," he says, kissing the top of your head. "I love you too pretty boy," you reply, smiling.

Chip ~ You do. You and Chip were sitting outside of school after school one day. You were going to stay the night with him and you were beyond excited. He was too. "Chip, can I tell you something?" You ask, smiling at him. "Of course! You can tell me anything," Chip replies smiling back at you. "I love you," you say, kissing him on the check. "I love you too," he replies, kissing you on the forehead.

William ~ He does. You were staying the night at Will's and you two were going to bed. You and Will were laying in his bead, you laying on his chest, his arms wrapped around you. You were almost asleep when you heard Will mutter it. "I love you, sweet pea," he whispered, kissing the top of your head. You smiled, "I love you too, Will," you say, slowly falling asleep.