Dean: He gets u a key to his "baby"
Sam: he gets u a locket with a pic of you too
Cas: gets u a matching trench coat to match his
Crowley: Gets you your very own Hell Hound
Chuck: He gets you your favorite book and reads it out loud to you.
Lucifer: He gets u a ticket to your favorite band.
Kevin: he got you the best sex u ever had.
YOU ARE READING
Supernatural Preferences/imagines
FanfictionDean, Sam, Castiel, Crowley, Chuck, Lucifer, and Kevin