Confusing Love

Chapter Two

I layed in my bed, one arm thrown over my forehead, and stared at the ceiling.
"I just need a friend." i whispered to myself, letting a tear escape and run down my face.
My parents werent home, so i was alone, as always.

"A friend you say?" A raspy voice came from my closet. The door slowly opened and a guy, around my age, came out. His hair was black and singed, his skin pale and leathery, and he had a smile cut wide into either sides of his face.

"J-Jeff?" I whispered. His eye's widened into surprise.
"How do you know who i am?"
"Y-Your my f-favorite C-Creepypasta c-character." I stuttered. He walked over and placed the tip of his knife under my chin, slowly raising my face to look at him.

"You're a pretty one." He said, slowly. I felt fear etched into my bones and heat rise to my face.
"T-thanks?"
He smiled and grabbed my wrist, putting his knife into his pocket with the other hand. He dragged me down stairs and pulled me out of my house.
"Hey! Where are we going?!" I yelled. He took his knife out and pointed it at me. He put a finger to his lips and continued to pull me towards the woods.
"C-can i at least text my f-friend so he wont get worried?"
Jeff stopped and looked at me. He started growling and pulled me closer.
"He?" He growled. I slowly nodded. It took me a second but i realized the situation.
"He's just a friend. I promise!" I said, holding my hands in front of me. His hand was still tightly gripping my wrist.
"Ow!" I said, trying to get loose of his grasp. He loosened it a little, just so he wasn't hurting me still.

We came to a large house in the forest and Jeff pushed me inside. I stopped to look around. I noticed other people there too. They all watched me and Jeff as he dragged me upstairs.
"Hey, You BEN Drowned! And your Eyeless Jack! And Slender Man!" I said, pointing at them.
"Hey Jeff, Who's the smart hottie you dragged in?" BEN called.
"SHUT THE HELL UP BEN!" Jeff yelled. Slendy put his hand to his forehead and walked out of the room. Jeff tugged on my arm and i followed upstairs.

He threw me down on a bed and went over to a sink and washed the blood off his knife. I awkwardly sat there and just watched him.
"So...Serial Killer, huh?" I asked him. He glared at me over his shoulder and snarled. I jumped and put my hands out in front of me.
"Okay! Sorry!" I said. He smirked at me.

I heard loud footsteps and then a loud knock on the door.
"FUCK OFF BEN!" Jeff yelled at the door. I heard the footsteps go back down the stairs then my phone started buzzing.
"Shit! Turn your phone off!" Jeff said, pointing at my phone. I scrambled to get my phone and turn it off but i didn't get to it in time. BEN crawled out and smirked at me.
"Ya like that?" He asked, winking. A knife flew past him and pinned him to the wall.
"Mine." Jeff growled. BEN chuckled and pulled the knife out of the wall and slung it back at Jeff, who caught it in mid-air.
"Oh really?" BEN said, coming up to me and holding my chin, forcing me to look into his black and red eyes.
"How about we ask her? What do you think, sweetheart?" BEN asked.

I gluped loudly and held my head down.
"Um...i-i guess J-Jeff because i-i've known him l-longer." I said quietly.
BEN scoffed and started towards the door. I got up and grabbed his wrist.
"We can be friends though." I said, giving him a small smile. He winked at me and walked out the door. I turned around and Jeff was scowling at me.

"Okay. Now. I want you to be mine." He said. I looked at him with wide eyes.
"W-what?"
"Oh! I got it!" He yelled, throwing his knife in the wall so it stayed. I jumped at the sudden movement.
"Let's play a game. " He said, smiling wider than usual.