"Me and you are gunna play a game." Jeff said, pointing his knife at me. I gulped and nodded quickly.
"Do you like me? Like...more than a friend?" He asked, trying to be seductive.
"N-not really...no.."
"WHAT?!" He shouted, obviously surprised.
"I-im sorry."
"But you said i was your favorite!" He shouted."Hey, i heard s-shouting and stuttering. What the h-hell are you doing i-in here J-jeff?" A voice called out from the door.
"Ben and T-Toby are also my f-favorites." I replied to Jeff, not paying any attention to the person at the door. Jeff looked shocked and then scowled at something behind me."W-what?" I asked, turning around. I came face to face with a pair of orange goggles.
"No. Fucking. Way."
I squealed and jumped into his arms.
"You don't know how much i love you!!" I said, hugging Toby.
Jeff just snarled. I giggled and walked over to him, kissing his cheek.
"I mean, if you want, i guess i could get used to loving you too.~"I felt my phone buzz and went to look at it.
Fang: Oh....okay...hope you feel better!
I looked at my phone confused and scrolled through my messages.
"What's your problem?" Jeff asked, looking over my shoulder.
"My friend, Fang texted me, telling me to feel better.""Fang?!" Toby asked, looking up suddenly.
"Y-yeah.... He looks alot like you actually, Toby. Same brown hair, same hazel eyes, same body figure. I guess that's why i liked him so much...."
"O-oh...Thanks?"I looked back at my phone and saw a message i didn't send.
Me: Hey Fang, im really sick, so i won't be going to school anytime soon.
"Oh, okay.....Don't remember sending that." I whispered to myself as Jeff and Toby started talking about something. Suddenly my phone started ringing, and a My Chemical Romance song started blaring. I looked at the caller ID and all it said was,
"You shouldn't have done that."I showed Jeff quickly and he just waved me off.
"Ben?"
"Yeah."
"You scared the shit outta me!"
"That's my job. Anyway, i just wanna tell you, i hacked your phone and texted your boyfriend."
I gasped at the word boyfriend."HE'S NOT MY BOYFRIEND!" I accidently yelled. Jeff and Toby looked at me, questionably.
"Heh heh, sorry.""Haha, Toby has a surprise for you, by the way. But that's none of my business. Why don't you text your little friend back?"
Ben was starting to act weird.....
"O-okay?"My phone started buzzing again and Ben popped out.
"I gotta see this."
"What the hell are you talking about?!" I asked him, pulling up my messages. He just smirked and sat down on the bed. Jeff smacked him upside the head.
"Shut the hell up, Ben!!" He yelled.I ignored them and typed my message to Fang.
Me: Haha, thanks bud. Ttyl.No more than a minute after, Toby's phone started making noises. My eyes widened when it was the same ring-tone i had for mine.
"F-Fang?!"
Toby pulled down his mouth gard and took his goggles up. He then looked down at his phone and typed something, looking back up.
I felt my phone vibrate and slowly looked at it.Fang: Surprise!!
YOU ARE READING
Confusing Love
RandomTicci Toby X Reader X Jeff the Killer Giggle. Read it cuz it coot