New Girl, Sids Charm (Sid Jenkins x Reader)

Missing Pieces

Three days had passed since the hazy night at Tony's, and Y/N couldn't shake the feeling of unease that lingered in the pit of her stomach. The whispers of the town seemed to follow her every step, and the weight of the unspoken events pressed down on her shoulders.

One morning, Y/N reached up to her ears, only to realize that her favorite pair of earrings was missing. Panic surged through her veins as she retraced her steps, memories of the night at Tony's flooding back. With a sinking feeling, she recalled leaving them somewhere in Tony's house.

Determined to retrieve her missing earrings, Y/N made her way to Tony's house. The familiar knot of guilt tightened in her stomach as she approached the door. The aftermath of that night still haunted her thoughts.

Upon entering, she was met by Tony and Michelle, who were casually chatting in the living room. Trying to mask her nerves, Y/N asked if they had seen her earrings. The exchanged glances between Tony and Michelle did not go unnoticed.

Tony, feigning innocence, said, "Earrings? Nope, haven't seen them."

Michelle, raising an eyebrow, added, "But we might know where they are. You left them at Sid's, didn't you?"

Y/N's heart skipped a beat, anxiety bubbling to the surface. "Sid's? Oh, right, I must have forgotten."

As the trio made their way to Tony's room, Y/N couldn't shake the sense that they knew more than they were letting on. The room, still bearing the traces of that fateful night, felt like a silent witness to the secrets hidden within its walls.

Upon seeing the earrings on Sid's bedside table, Tony and Michelle exchanged knowing glances. Y/N, realizing the implication, felt a lump forming in her throat.

"Y/N," Michelle began, her tone a mix of concern and curiosity, "what really happened that night with Sid?"

Y/N, unable to recall the details, shrugged anxiously. "I... I honestly don't remember much. It's all a blur."

Tony, ever the provocateur, leaned in. "A blur, or are you just not telling us something?"

A series of questions followed, each more probing than the last, as Y/N struggled to provide coherent answers. The weight of suspicion hung in the air, and Tony and Michelle exchanged glances, signaling an unspoken understanding.

"I think we should tell the rest of the gang," Michelle suggested, her gaze fixed on Y/N.

Tony nodded in agreement, "They deserve to know the truth."

As the news spread through the friend group, the atmosphere shifted. Conversations echoed through the town:

Anwar to Chris: "Y/N is hiding something. Did you see the way she looked when we found the earrings?"

Maxxie to Jal: "This is turning into a real drama. What do you think happened between Y/N and Sid?"

Chris to Anwar: "I bet it's a love triangle. Classic soap opera material."

Jal to Michelle: "We need to talk to Sid. Get his side of the story."

Tony to Maxxie: "Y/N is definitely not telling us everything. We need to get to the bottom of this."

Anwar to Chris: "I never expected Y/N to be involved in something like this."

Michelle to Jal: "It's like a mystery unraveling. What happened between Y/N and Sid?"

Maxxie to Tony: "Let's gather everyone and find out the truth."

Chris to Anwar: "I bet this will be the talk of the town for weeks."

Jal to Michelle: "We need to handle this delicately. Y/N is one of us."

The tension in Bristol thickened as the truth remained elusive, hidden behind a haze of uncertainty and unspoken emotions. Y/N, grappling with the consequences of that mysterious night, now found herself at the center of a storm that threatened to upend the delicate balance of friendships within the tight-knit group.