Creepypasta x Reader

Chap. 4 - Imaginary Friend

"It's not like Slender isn't already aware of you having a demon. That's why he took you in as one of his Proxy instead of killing you, y'know that right?" Eyeless Jack was stood before the much smaller girl, unceremoniously he'd been brought to Maggie's bedroom after the display he witnessed which for a human he did find impressive after all. "I never thought he'd come out, this was the first time because of Masky trying to fucking rape me or whatever he had planned." He did notice that when he'd found Maggie she was closer to Masky and Hoodie's shared bedroom, that made a lot more sense for an old shadow Deva to come out for that reason to protect its master. "You got lucky you have a Deva otherwise Masky would have done it. Don't be unarmed in this place with any of us, even me." The sentence alone struck a chord in the girl as she watched him look around the bedroom, ever since arriving it appeared that Slender or someone had put all the items in her room including furniture the same as her bedroom at home. Every single thing she owned, even the closet was full of her items and the same as she recalled even the smell, her scent remained on everything in the bedroom which Jack himself found to be intoxicating. "I'll remember that, please keep my secret. No one knows besides you and that cunt and Slender." Jack still continued to look around, his large form bigger than Masky and Hoodie seemed to look out of place inside of her bedroom but he spoke in that same voice he used. "Sure if you answer this for me. How come whenever I see you in this mansion I can smell your arousal." If her face could get any redder it would have as Maggie put a hand over her eyes, primarily in shame due to how she forgot that Jack had the keenest sense of smell out of all the creepypastas. "I-I can um I can explain! Listen, before I got here all of you are fictional characters on the internet I was obsessed with for years. I know it's weird but I have had a crush on you since middle school, don't laugh! Masky made fun of me for it but I can't help it!" Not a singular ounce of shame was left inside of her body, even if it felt too embarrassing to admit and have now five of the people be aware of such a very silly thing. "On me?" Initially after his shock and being explained the entirety of the creepypastas like Masky and Toby and Hoodie he took in the information like a sponge albeit more confused than the other Proxies. "Uh yeah, not to be um weird but I do think you're very attractive still." Now that shocked him, sure all the freaks in the mansion sometimes had sexual relations amongst one another or their victims, nothing was unheard of in Slender's mansion but to be the works of fiction and crushed on or feelings being had for them was something new to the demon hybrid. "Really now, is that so? Tell me more." Leaning in closer, even without eyes and his mask covering the entirety of Jack's face he could see the blush on her face that'd grown from his close proximity, "Y-Y-Yes...!" He actually laughed and for some reason she felt oddly aroused by the sound of his voice more and more, which she knew his nose was going to pick up on. "I haven't even done anything to you and your scent is filling up the room." For all it was worth she did try to keep her thighs pressed tightly together, even Jack noticed it from the beginning how she squirmed under his eyeless masked gaze. "N-not my fault, it's yours for talking in that tone. I mean what? Ah ha...please pretend you can't smell like a blood hound." Maggie pleaded as she hid her face in both hands, the sight endearing to the serial killer that ate kidneys since he'd never had a pretty girl at that have a crush on him or get aroused just by the sight of him or hearing his voice. "No can do. If you wanna make it up to me, come see me in the infirmary more. And I'll keep that little secret of yours." Blushing so profusely he could hear the way her blood had rushed to that pretty face, part of him felt an inhumane urge to just bite into Maggie's pale delicate little neck but figured after they got to know each other more he could pursue it. "Got it! Then we're friends now? I always wanted to be friends with you!" Maggie threw her arms around Jack's torso, which was about as much as she could reach, grinning so manic that he pondered if this was what it was like to have a fan. "We can be friends, for now yeah. I didn't expect you to hug me though." That made her arousal shoot up further, causing Jack to bite his lip with the sharp canines underneath his mask and he couldn't deny feeling her up so close felt pretty good. His toned muscles under the hoodie he wore against the biggest pair of real boobs him and anyone else in the manor had ever seen, she was thick and about 5'7 or 8 but still got dwarfed by the large entities in Slenderman's mansion, including Eyeless Jack.  "Sorry I-I uh got too excited! Next time I'll ask, I promise Jack." Finding himself enjoying how she spoke his name, the hybrid left her room in good spirits after they said goodbye but he'd run into Masky outside of Maggie's bedroom. "Move, you're in my way." Barking orders was a common occurrence for Masky as the eldest Proxy, however Jack did not fall into the Proxy category and often refused orders that came from Masky unless someone was wounded. "You aren't Slender and I'm not letting you in Maggie's room." A loud and audible sigh fell from Masky behind the mask, "Oh? Don't tell me you like her, seriously? If you want after I'm done killing her you can have her kidneys." The threat hung in the air, Jack assuming that her demons blow to Masky and his ego after she told him what transpired between them, a tiny smirk wove its way on Jack's face. "Yeah right, the demon inside her will throw you around like he did in your room." Growling at Jack, Masky shoved past him and opened the bedroom door only to see the gigantic hulking mass of a demon already there. Maggie's form covered by the sheer size of the seven foot tall being who stood only five inches taller than Jack, "Get away." Its demonic voice had a feral tone despite its semi human appearance, big black claws glinting dangerously in the low light of the Victorian mansions lighting, Masky and Eyeless Jack shared a look. Instead of being a civil person, Masky attempted to fight Martin only to be thrown around the hallway like a rag doll in front of both Jack and Maggie, feeling like a chew doll as Martin bared his fangs and even bit into his sleeve. "Well, now I don't have to be scared of you. Let him go Martin. Get out of my sight Tim." Maggie stood with her arms crossed over her chest, "You must be joking, I'll fucking kill you when I get the chance bitch. Demon or not, you still gotta sleep sometime Maggie." Masky was on his feet, he chuckled despite the way she glared menacingly at the Proxy and even if this had made them enemies permanently she didn't mind. "Try it, I promise you that I won't be the one dying Timothy." Maggie slammed the door shut, Masky and Jack standing in the silence as a new aura permeated between the two killers inside the hallway. Both had found out they harbored a strange range of feelings for Maggie albeit Masky's were far darker, he wanted to claim and rape and taint her due to the fact she'd caused him to feel attraction, that alone was enough to earn his anger, abuse and make her hate him. However the more they argued and got into physical spats instead of lessening his urges, it increased them, Masky was unable to let go of his misogynistic bigotry to admit he had feelings so instead he tormented her like the rest of the Proxies aside from Hoodie and now there was no way he could restore her crush on him. Not after what he tried to do and Jack knew Maggie not only hated Masky but wanted to kill him, eventually maybe she could but the operator would never allow them to kill one another, instead this was a test to see how Maggie handled Masky and using a demon she overcame the test. Jack on the other hand simply wanted to be her friend and slowly try to understand why she liked him, a crush and a friendship were two new things for the eyeless hybrid and he was overjoyed that they could share a common enemy. No one liked Masky, aside from Hoodie and the few who had the ability to tolerate his domineering ass, which was not many of the serial killers in the house and he wanted to see how the feud between the Proxy and the Agent would go after this event.