Do You Still Love Me?

Chapter 1

A/N okay so I added a character. And the original cover had the words 'Do You Still Love Me?' but it was too wide so I had to crop it down to 'Love Me?' Still looks good right? Anyway on with the story! Listening to Of Mice & Men "You Make Me Sick" and Arch Enemy "You Will Know My Name" while writing this

Onyx's point of view

Its been nearly a month since I left Jeff, I still remember that night clearly. In all honesty I haven't been as happy, and I'm sure he isn't either. Don't get me wrong, I do miss him but, can I really blame him for what happened? Is there anyone to blame? Maybe I should give him another chance. He's doing everything he can to get me back. He even brought me someone's, still beating, heart. I know it sounds weird, but to me it was sweet that he went through all the trouble to get me and still beating heart, after all they are my favorites of trophies. I would get back together with Jeff, but I'm scared. 'Should I blame him? Could I? Should I even be here? Or should I leave? Maybe.' I was deep in thought when I heard a knock at the door.

Toby looked over at me, I loved Toby like a little brother. I guess to him I was like the big sister he lost, he was always a little clingy to me but I didn't mind. I got up off the couch and my gaze sharpened as I heard another knock. 'Who would be out this late, with this storm' I thought as I opened the door. There was a tall man with shoulder length brown hair. Green eyes and stitches on his face. He had a gray and black striped scarf around his neck. A green shirt that brought out his eyes quite nicely, with a black jacket. "Um, I was hoping I could have some shelter for hopefully just tonight. I'll be in my way in the morning." He said with a sheepish smile. I blinked a couple of times and smiled brightly. "Of course, come inside" I said.

He stepped inside and I told him I'd have to ask the head of the household first. He decided to wait with Toby, I was a little worried about him waiting with Toby, Toby isn't exactly open with others but I know he can protect himself. "Slendy" I called as I walked to the kitchen. I knew Slender hated being called that. "I told you child do not call me that, and what are you yelling about?" Slender said as he walked out of the kitchen. "Can this man stay for the night, he was caught up in the rain and needed shelter." I said. Slender thought for a moment. "Where is he?" He asked. "In the living room with Toby" I said. Slender walked in the living room and made eye contact with the man. The man walked up to Slender, and held out a hand. "Evening, name's Liu" he said as Slender shook his hand. My eyes widened at that name. I remembered Jeff talking dearly of a guy named Liu.

-Flashback-

Authors point of view

Onyx and Jeff were in Jeff's room cuddling. Onyx looked over and on Jeff's nightstand she saw a picture of him before the accident and another guy. Her head popped up and she took a closer look at the picture. "What's wrong babe?" Jeff said with his face barried in her neck. "Jeff?" She said. He looked up and responded with a "hmmmm?" She picked up the photo and looked closer at it! She instantly heard Jeff's heart speed up. "Jeff who is this?" She asked. He chuckled trying to remain calm. "Oh that, its just me before the whole accident thing. Why? You don't want me that way do you?" Jeff said trying to hide the pain in his eyes. Onyx rolled her eyes. "No, I love the way you are now. I meant the other guy you smartass, I know that's you." She said as she pointed to the picture. Jeff sighed. "That's my older brother, Liu. He's dead now though, he's dead because I killed him along with our parents so don't ask how that all happened. Its old wounds okay? Old wounds." Jeff said as his voice cracked a little. Onyx put down the photo and wrapped her arms around his neck and rubbed his head. "Its okay, you didn't mean to. It'll all be okay Jeff" she said as he weeped in her shoulder.

-Flashback over-

Onyx's point of view

'That was a while back. While we were still together, now we're broken. I need to tell Jeff that he's alive, give Jeff a light in his life again' I thought. "You may stay" Slender said, knowing good and well that this was Jeff's brother. I grabbed Liu's hand and lead him down the hall. "There's someone you gave to meet." I said happily. I came to Jeff's room that had the usual 'do not enter' wrote in black on it. I knocked on the door. "Come in," Jeff's low raispy voice said. I opened the door and saw Jeff on his bed, laying on his stomach. "Someone needs to meet you!" I said happily. Jeff didn't look up at me. "Who?" He said. "Jeff?!" Liu called out in shock. Jeff shot right up at that voice. Jeff looked in our direction. There was a sparkle in his eyes, Liu ran up to him and hugged him. Jeff hugged back, crying instantly. "Y-you're alive? I t-thought I k-killed" Liu cut Jeff off. "But I lived! And we're finally back together. A tear fell at this heart felt moment. Jeff had happiness back in his once again.

A/N I literally just realized that Hollywood Undead is like the band of the Creepypastas.