My Judgement Day (Rhea Ripley X Male Reader)

Which Do You Prefer?

I ran into a problem. 

I was going to have Y/N defeat Roman Reigns at Wrestlemania 39 but it brings up too many complications.

I had this whole backstory planned about Y/N versus Roman Reigns for the first time back in 2021 after winning the Battle Royal.  

(You know when Sami versed Roman Reigns for the Universal Title and then Brock attacked him before the match started and he was squashed)

It's not important, he would have lost, and then at Wrestlemania Thirty Nine he won in the main event. (The 2023 Bloodline Civil War can still go ahead) 

Y/N would be Champion on Raw and Seth would be Champion on Smackdown.

So my problem is that if Y/N wins the title changes too many things. Because Damian wouldn't screw Finn at Money in the Bank or at Summerslam. How would I be able to write about Finn's jealousy? 

* I think writing it as Y/N and Damian are both world champions while Finn isn't because I really want to Y/N dethrone Roman at 39.

Option One) Y/N wins the Undisputed Champion at Wrestlemania 39

Backlash: AJ Styles.

Night of Champions: Brock Lesnar

Brock would attack him at the crowning ceremony where he gets the new title. Y/N would beat him but Brock would attack him afterwards. Y/N would issue an open challenge but Shinsuke Nakamura attacked him with the mist. 

Money in the Bank: Shinsuke Nakamura. 

Y/N would beat Shinsuke for the title but Shinsuke attacked him from behind. Y/N issued an I-Quit match at Money in the Bank.

Summerslam: Brock Lesnar

There would be this whole story about Y/N worrying Damian would cash in on him. But at Summerslam, Damian comes down to ringside to support Y/N L/N and is attacked by his opponent. Brock Lesnar, Y/N would power through and do what Damian did against Gunther for attacking Finn and winning the match. 

Finn and Damian would verse the Mysterios for the Smackdown Tag Titles.

Payback: Drew Mcyintre.  Kevin Owens and Sami Zayn

Finn and Damian would become Undisputed Tag Champs.

Fastlane: Braun Strowman

Finn and Damian would lose it at Fastlane. Y/N would get attacked by Strowman constantly so Y/N issued the challenge.

Crown Jewel: Jey Uso. (Especially with the flirting stuff. Y/N would get pissed off and issue a Hell in a Cell match)

Survivor Series: Wargames. World Champ vs World Champ. Team Y/N Vs Team Seth. Judgment Day and Drew vs Seth Rollins, Sami Zayn, Kevin Owens, Jey Uso, Randy Orton)

Day One: Drew Mcyintre (As a thanks for teaming with him)

Royal Rumble: Randy Orton. (He returned at Wargames for Team Seth. The Judgment Day would lose but Y/N wanted a match.)

Roman comes back and wins the 2024 Royal Rumble challenging Y/N for the title again. This time with backup. The Rock. They make things difficult for the Judgment Day specifically Rhea and Y/N but they preserve.

Elimination Chamber: Doesn't do anything. (Goes to Perth and accepts the challenge for a tag team match)

Wrestlemania 40: Y/N and Seth vs Roman and Rock. Then Bloodline Rules if Roman loses he can't challenge for the title.

Y/N has an idea for Damian to cash in on him in the Wrestlemania Main Event so that the Universal Title stays with the Judgment Day but Damian goes against cashing in on Drew Mcyintre and winning the World Heavyweight Championship. Y/N was annoyed but happy that someone he considers like a brother won the title.

Y/N beats Roman in Bloodline Rules ending the trilogy with Y/N the victor but the Rock was in his rearview mirror.

Rhea would be injured by Liv two weeks before the draft and Y/N would want to give up the title to be with Rhea. But she told him not to so that he could show Damian the ropes of being a world champion.

The Universal title is drafted to smackdown but Y/N would become a free agent. He would be on both Smackdown and Raw so that he can deal with the Liv situation and defend his title.

Option Two) if Y/N loses at Wrestlemania 39. 

The matches will be less varied but more personal and the tensions will be more because of Y/N not trusting the Judgment Day anymore, thinking there's a traitor and he's thinks it Damian.

Payback: Brock Lesnar.

Night of Champions: Brock Lesnar.

Money in the Bank: Brock Lesnar. (End of feud)

He challenges Seth the Raw after Summerslam both Finn and Damian screw him in the same match.

Summerslam: Becomes Smackdown Tag Champs beating the Mysterios. (Unknown tag partner not Judgment Day)

Has to give up the title the next night because of the age and gender of his tag partner.

Payback: Becomes Undisputed Tag Champ with Finn.

Fastlane: Loses tag title to Jey and Sami.

Raw Premiere: Becomes Tag Champs with Damian. (Rhea forces him to bury the hatchet)

Crown Jewel: He verses Jey Uso in a Hell in a Cell match.  (Especially with the flirting stuff. Y/N would get pissed off and issue a Hell in a Cell match)

Survivor Series: The Battle of Who Runs Raw. Team Judgment Day and Drew Mcyintre vs Seth, Kevin Owens, Sami Zayn, Jey Uso, and Randy Orton

Royal Rumble: Wins the match. (Tensions Rise within Judgment Day again with Y/N not trusting Damian thinking he would cash in on him. But still had to be the tag title champions)

Elimination Chamber: Accepts Challenge with Seth after defending the tag titles.

Wrestlemania: Defeats Roman in Bloodline Rules.

So which one do you want to see more? 

Option One Or Option Two.

The next chapter is coming soon. I'm trying to make the confrontation between Y/N and Damian against the Usos on the Smackdown before Elimination Chamber seem more personal with both issuing low shots.