The Iron Nightfury

4th girlfriend 52

Normal p.o.v

Few days

Anna has been keeping the Black mail a secret for a long time texting Hiccup whenever shes in the mood and Hiccup texting back whenever hes in the mood keeping up with their deal but it also made the others suspicious of Hiccup and what he was doing so they had a small secret meeting with eachother "so got any ideas what Hiccup is hiding this time" Elsa said who was sitting on the bed while Heather was on her Tablet "I'm not seeing anything new on Hiccups systems so hes definently not making anything" Heather said and turned off her Tablet "it's like hes avoiding us sort of" Astrid said who was pacing back and forth

"You dont think he has a secret 4th do you" Heather said and looked at the others referring to another girlfriend "atleast I hope not I mean the only people are us, Gustav and Anna but I dont think Anna has a crush on Hiccup does she" Elsa said thinking the possibilities

Meantime with Hiccup

Both Hiccup and Anna were using the same shower for their private time with Hiccup carrying Anna and Anna had her legs wrapped around Hiccups torso and had her pinned to the wall and was thrusting inside of her at a rapid pace "Ugh.yes, yes, yes" Anna said grining her teeth while feeling Hiccup inside of her "please tell me your... using birth control" Hiccup said and looked at Anna who wrapped her hand behind Hiccups neck "How about...just worry... about satisfying yourself" Anna said and grabbed Hiccups other hand and placed it around her breast and placed a gentle kiss on his lips in which Hiccup returned and just in time because Anna was just about there till she finally her her Orgasm and Hiccup was following her lead and came as well and grabbe one final thrust before leaving it in there for awhile as Anna let out a big mean moan inside of Hiccups mouth as they exchanged some saliva

Hiccup them pulled out and semen began flowing out of Anna and into the drain, Hiccup then stepped out and grabbed a towel for him and Anna and wrapped it around their bodies "here I'll leave first and wait a couple of minutes" Hiccup said and opened the door and looked around and got out and closed the door and went to his room, just when he walked in he heard the door close and looked at it only to see the others "Uh ladies hows is going" Hiccup said and let out a nervous smile seeing all 3 of them having their arms crossed and giving Hiccup evil glares "alright spill it Hiccup who's the other" Astrid said as all 3 girls began circuling Hiccup like a pack of wolves

"Other whatever do you mean" Hiccup said only for Elsa to grab the towel and expose Hiccups member "see you might say something diffrent but atleast part of your thing is honest" Elsa said as all girls pushed Hiccup to the bed "spill what are you up to" Heather said as Hiccup let out a sight and looked down
"Look a couple of nights ago my body went into Overdrive and I tried to feel for one of you but...I did but it wasnt one of you" Hiccup said and saw the girls with a confused look and waited for an Explanation "look the other one you mentioned Heather it was....Anna" Hiccup said and closed his eyes waiting for punishment "wait Anna crawled into bed without us knowing" Astrid said only for Hiccup to nod "yes and she didnt say anything and you know one thing led to another and before I knew it I was halfway done before I realised it was Anna" Hiccup said and felt a hand on his shoulder "so you took my sisters first time" Elsa said and we were very close as I just grabbed her wrist "and shes blackmailing me" Hiccup said and gently puts her hands down "wait blackmail why is she blackmailing you" Heather asked and began thinking of what kind of dirt she had on Hiccup "she didnt threaten to expose your identity did she" Elsa said feeling ashamed that her sister would do something like that "what no and give me that towel, shes threaten to tell you guys of what I did" Hiccup said and looked at the others expression only for them to look at eachother and bursted put laughing at the same time "really Hiccup threaten to say that you took her first time look we belive you but if it was something like you force forced yourself on Anna that wouldve been a diffrent story" Heather said and placed her hand on Hiccups shoulder