Human!Bonnie X Shy!Reader X Human! Freddy X Golden Freddy

Chapter 14

After the whole ordeal with the "Fifty Shades of Grey" book, Chica and Y/n were left with a small clue about sex. "Ok so he just puts his d*ck in her p*ssy, and that's it? That's so simple!" "Ch-Chica, the surprise is almost done." "Oh ok. Let's get the frosting out!"

They got the frosting and food coloring out of the grocery bag. Y/n and Chica colored a quarter of it purple, a quarter of it brown, a quarter yellow, and a quarter of it f/c. The oven beeped, signaling the surprise was done. Y/n and Chica took out the surprise from the oven and frosted it.

~MEANWHILE~

"Ok, after all that, I think I got it." Said Bonnie. "Right, so you put your 'sex part' inside of either her sex part, or her booty, and you, uh, help me out here." "You go back and forth." Bonnie finished. "Yes! That's it!" Freddy and Bonnie high-fived. "I'm proud of us." Said Freddy. "Me too!"

"Ok, well, before we go, Goldie also told me about other things to do during sex, or before, to get her in the mood. "Like what?" Freddy went on to explain other things for sex to Bonnie. "..and then her neck, your gonna wanna kiss and/or lick it till she moans from pleasure. After-"

There was a knock on the door. "Fr-Freddy, Bonnie, the s-surprise is ready." Freddy did the 'lip zip' sign to Bonnie. "Coming!" Called Freddy. Both him and Bonnie went out and into the dining room. Sat in the middle of the dining room, was a plate full of cookies with different colored frosting on them.

"Take whichever ones you want." Chica said. Y/n and Chica sat down at a table with a couple cookies on their plate. Freddy and Bonnie got some of the cookies as well and sat down with Y/n and Chica. They ate in silence for a moment, until Chica nudged Y/n. Y/n nodded and broke the silence.

"Um, Freddy, Bonnie... You kn-know how you t-told me to choose which one o-of you I wanted?" "Yeah..." They both said, dreading, knowing only one can have her. "I can't ch-choose. I love you b-both." Freddy looked at Bonnie and Bonnie looked at Freddy. Both had wide eyes. "But what about first kiss?" Asked Bonnie. "And first sex partner?" Asked Freddy.

"You two decide who gets the first kiss, and then you can share her in sex. Isn't there two ways to have sex?" "Oh, right." "I have an idea. We both know which side we want, so we could flip her first kiss?" "I'm okay with that, are you okay with it, Y/n?" Asked Bonnie. "Y-Yeah."

Bonnie went and got a coin. "Ok Freddy, do you want this weird guy's head, or this building?" "The guy's head." Bonnie flipped it and it landed on the building. Looks like your first kiss is Bonnie.