That Eyeless Stare

Chapter Four: Now Or Never

Walking home from Scarlet's house, I kept asking myself questions; Why is it I haven't killed her? How come I'm close to her; her little piece of heaven? I finally am back at the Slender Mansion, and I walk in the door; everything is like it always is.
BEN, Dark Link, Glitchy Red, & Lost Silver are playing on the ps4. Jeff is passed out in his chair; Slenderman is cooking in the kitchen with his brothers; The girls are probably upstairs doing girly things. The proxies probably out doing chores for their master.
I sigh and set my bag down on the floor, and look up to see Jeff in my face.
"Where have you been, EJ?" Says Jeff, looking at me with that eternal smile of his.
"I was out getting kidneys. Is that okay?" I snap at him. There is no way I'm going to tell him where I've been. He'll tell Slenderman.
"Oh really? Then how come you don't have any on you, and you smell like a girl?" He says snickering. He had said it loud enough for other people to hear, so they start coming over.
"Were you really with a girl? I can smell it too!" Says BEN, being a pervert like always.
"Just tell us Jack. Maybe Slenderman won't care." Says Glitchy Red, glitching.
"C-Come on, E-Ej." Says Lost Silver, stuttering like always.
"Even if I was, I wouldn't tell any of you brainless idiots." I say, walking away to my room.
Jeff follows me the whole way, irritating the fuck out of me.
"Tell me EJ. I wont tell Slenderman." Says Jeff every other five seconds.
"Fine! I'll fucking tell you!" I say, snapping at him. We walk into his room, and I tell him the whole story.
"Sounds like you are in love with this Scarlet!" Says Jeff, snickering.
"Y-You really T-think I l-l-like her?" I say, stuttering up a storm.
"Yep! I do! Now if I were you, I would ask Slenderman to make her a creepy pasta. If you don't, one of us might get her first... Either that, or mark her and make her a creepy pasta." Says Jeff laughing and messing with his favorite kitchen knife.
"Keep your fucking hands off her! And... I already marked her." I say, taking away eye contact with Jeff.
"Oh. And where would that be?" Says Jeff, clearly not believing me.
"Her left eye... has two scars on it from being cut with a knife..." I say.
"Well, you need to tell Slenderman, or I will!" Says Jeff, his smile seeming to get bigger.
"You wouldn't fucking dare!" I say, getting out my scalpel.
"Then you go tell him! Right now!" Says Jeff demonically.
"F-Fine..." I say, getting up from where I was sitting.
Making my way down the stairs from my room, I head into the kitchen. I find Slenderman alone, sitting at the table.
"What is it, Child?" Says Slenderman, already knowing I wanted to talk to him.
"W-well... There is a girl... That I saved from her father a few years ago... and... I think that I really l-l-l-like her, sir." I say, my face getting flush, but he wouldn't know that because of my mask.
"And what would it be you're trying to get at, EJ?" Says Slenderman, his hands folded together.
"I... wanted to know i-if she could become c-creepy pasta like us because I-I don't want any of the others k-k-killing her, sir." I say, rubbing my sweaty neck.
"I will consider it, only because you have been a good child, and you have never broke any of my rules. When would you want this to be?" Says Slenderman, his faceless face seems to be slightly joyful at the thought of another child.
"I-I don't know sir. She doesn't know that I like her." I say, slightly embarrassed.
"Well, we need to do it soon. It's Now or Never child. One of them are bound to go after her, even if you have marked her." Says Slenderman, sighing.
"I'll tell her tomorrow, sir. And... thank you." I say, leaning against the wall.
"Now this is what I want you to do; I want you to tell the others, and have them be on their best behavior. Just because their killers does not mean that they can be animals." Says Slenderman chuckling.
"Y-yes, sir." I say, walking out of the door.
*~*
I tell all of the creepy pastas in the household of the new arrival that would be coming.
"I knew it..." Says Ben.
"I'm happy on the other hand. At least there will be another girl." Says Jane, crossing her arms and chuckling.
"C-cool. A new k-kitty." Says Ticci Toby, cracking his neck, and at the same time, Clockwork pushes him to the ground.
"When will she be coming?" Says Glitchy Red.
"Tomorrow..." I say.
Everyone freaks out and starts running around.
"What the fuck you could have told us that!" Says BEN.
"I'm going to go get my dollies!" Says Sally cheerfully.
A little surprised by all of the commotion, I go back to Scarlet's house. I'm surprised nobody saw me leave. I thought someone would try to follow me.
"Hey, don't think you're leaving without my beautiful face." Says Jeff, snickering.
"I never asked you to come." I say, ignoring what he was saying and continued walking on.
"Well to bad. I'm coming with you." Says Jeff as he calls his dog, Smile.
"Whatever, Jeff." I say, getting ready for how I would say this to Scarlet.