Judges Review - Romance

15 5 0
                                    

Slightly different judging. Sorry! 

1st place: You Said forever and always @lostlovefairy


I like your cover it's very good but maybe a different font would go with it. Your title is good I feel like it's overused but it works well with your book! The blurb is good I enjoyed. The warning / author note was really nice and I love how you add the quotes for sexual abuse that was very good!

The chapters are good you are talented writer and I can't wait to finish it for Olivia's Reading Challenge.

Total: 99.5/100


2nd Place: Champagne Life - 7Bibliophile3

Cover and Aesthetics - 10/10

Very mysterious, beautiful font.

Title: 9/10

Very mysterious, but doesn't really give a hook.

Description: 10/10

Mysterious with a hook. Gives just enough information to be interesting. Good job!

Grammar 10/10

All are correct. If there are errors they were most likely too minor to be obvious.

Plot 20/20

Development 19/20

All characters have their own personality, some quite creative.

Enjoyment 8/10

Not really my thing, but the opening with hooking.

Total: 96/100


3rd place : Ancilla @SeraDrake

I enjoyed reading your book. To be fair I like the plot and your characters and the new cover is amazing! I don't think I have anything else to say!

Total: 95.5/100 

Canine Awards - ClosedWhere stories live. Discover now