I Need You Again (One Direction Fan Fiction, Sequel to Over Again)

Chapter 2 - Guilt and Deal Making

Niall's POV

"So, how are you taking it?" asked Liam. He walked over to me. He sat on the kitchen countertop. I was leaning on the counter top. He was looking down at me now. Nice like I already don't feel short enough.

"I don't understand," I said.

"Understand what?" asked Harry. Harry has been quite distant for a quite a while. It was quite surprising to see him talking more frequently now.

"I mean," I said taking  a pause to figure out my words. "I wrapped it up and everything and she said she was on birth control,"

"Well condoms break man," said Zayn.

"And Birth control doesn't always work," said Chanel. She had made her way over to Liam sitting on his lap. Guess they really missed each other. They couldn't be separated for more that a minute.

"Really?" asked Liam. He looked up at her since she was a bit tall since she was on his lap.

"Yea," she said. "But its smart to be on birth control,"

"You're on birth control right?" he asked. Chanel's eyebrows fitted into a frown, All hell was about to break loose. 

"Of course I am," she said. "What kind of question is that?"

"Woah," said Liam. He put his hands up in defense. "I was just asking, we don't want to take any risks,"

"And what if I got pregnant?" she asked. A frown was still on her face. "Would you leave me? Huh..." Chanel continued to rant on about how birth control doesn't always work. Liam sighed pinching the bridge of his nose. He stood up and put Chanel over his shoulder. 

"I'll be back guys," he said.

"Hey!" yelled Chanel. "Put me down! Eleanor help me,"

"Nope," said Eleanor. "I'm not apart of this,"

"What?" asked Chanel. "Liam!" she squealed as he slapped her ass. Snickers ran through the room. 

"But maybe Chanel's right," said Louis. "Birth control doesnt always work, are you thinking that its not your child?"

"Of course not," I said. "Kaitlyn would never cheat on me,"

I watched as Harry grabbed his coat and opened the door. "I'm going for a walk," he said and he closed the door behind him. What was his problem?

Harry's POV

I closed the door behind me. I felt as if the walls were coming in on me surrounding me with guilt. I sighed. I looked over to Kaitlyn's house next to mine. I fidgeted with my hands. Should I go over there?

I stopped fidgeting and I walked over to her house. I stood on the patio rocking back and forth. I finally forced my self to raise my hand and ring the doorbell. I heard steps coming toward the door. The door opened to reveal  a tired looking Kaitlyn in her pajamas.

"Harry?" she asked. "What are you doing here?"

"We need to talk," I said. Katy looked at me before stepping aside to let me in. I door walked by her. She closed the door behind her and she led me to the kitchen. 

"What?" she asked. I sighed mustering all the courage to say what I came here to say.

"How do you know that Lea is Niall's daughter?" I asked. 

Katy looked me straight in the eyes with barely any emotion on her face. "I don't," she said. 

"How are you just acting like nothing happened?" I asked. "Do you not feel any guilt from what happened at all?" I was starting to get angry. I looked away trying to restrain myself. I looked back at Kaitlyn to see that she was crying. 

"Everyday," she says. "Every fucking day I feel the guilt eating away at me inside but I can't tell  him, I don't want to see the sadness and disappointment in his face, I love him too much,"

"I want a fraternity test," I said. "If its mine we tell Niall, if it isn't we don't have to tell a soul, but if you don't let Lea test I'll tell Niall myself,"

"I can't," she said. "I just can't,"

"If you love Niall as much as you say you do," I paused and took a breath. "Then you'd do it for him, relationships rely on honesty," I looked at her one more time before exiting the door.