Captain Foxy: A FNAF Story

Chapter 2: The Puppet and the Cupcake

The crew knew they dodged a bullet with Commander Fazbear, so they continued their exploration of the port. Chica and Carl left to go try to find new crew members, while Foxy and Bonnie searched for riches. Foxy and Bonnie searched for hours, and eventually decided to give up. Chica and Carl, however, found someone they thought could be a useful crew member. He called himself the "Puppet". He claimed that he had a superior mind and very quick moving capabilities. Foxy decided to put this "Puppet" up to the test. Captain Foxy brought the Puppet to a secluded part of town, and took out his sword. The Puppet kept his promises, he outsmarted Foxy and before the captain knew it, the Puppet was gone. "Well, that didn't go as well as you thought it would, did it?" a voice called from behind Captain Foxy. It was the Puppet, and he was carrying Foxy's sword. Foxy was amazed and gladly accepted the Puppet into the crew. "Ye be needing some new garments, lad." Foxy stated, willing to buy him new clothes and weapons. The Puppet only had old an old shirt and ripped trousers, which definitely needed to go. Chica took him to the market and bought him an all-black sailor outfit that suited him greatly, and a pistol, just in case he can't use his mind to steal the enemy's weapon. After that, the Puppet was officially a new pirate.

The crew decided to stay in Port Fazbear for a few more days. Nothing that interesting really happened, except for one thing with Carl. Carl was told by Foxy to prepare a cake for the crew's last day in port, to celebrate new adventures. Except for one tiny thing, they had nothing to bake cake on. Foxy told Carl to just try to make things work, and that he would be just fine. Carl searched around the ship for something. He did find one thing, but he wasn't too certain about it. In the crew quarters, there was a mug in his cabinet. "This will have to do," Carl thought to himself, "There's nothing else in this wretched ship, anyway." He decided to bake a bunch of tiny cakes using the cup as a mold, which he decided to call "cupcakes". When the crew came aboard to see the cake Carl created, they were in for a surprise. The cakes didn't turn out how he expected. The mold worked, however it made a hole in the cake, which made it look like an actual mug. That's how Carl got the nickname, "Cupcake", and it stuck with him for the rest of his life.

Well, after the Cupcake's baking disaster, the Puppet, who was the new ship sailor, decided to take the steering wheel and leave the port. Their next destination was Balloons Island, which was only a few nights away from Port Fazbear. On Balloons Island, they hoped to meet with an old friend that they had a few years ago. Anyway, it was now nighttime and they were getting tired, so Bonnie and the Puppet decided to go downstairs. This was good news for Chica, because that meant she was finally alone with Foxy. Chica moved towards Foxy and knew that it was her chance to finally build a relationship with the love of her life. She talked to Foxy for a few minutes, and then leaned in for a kiss. Right before Foxy was about to realize Chica was going to kiss him, there was a big crash that came from the crew quarters. Captain Foxy ran down to see what the matter was. There, in the corner of the room, was Bonnie with his gun pointed at Commander Fazbear. "Why are you on our ship?" shouted Bonnie.