Slenderman:
He found your diary when cleaning your room while you were at school. It was filled with heart drawings and Slender's name scribbled on each page. Except one page that held your most greatest fear, spiders. He put the book exactly where it was under your pillow and continued cleaning.
Jeff the Killer:
He was just watching TV when he found your diary peaking out from the bookshelf next to the TV. He tried to ignore it, but the curiosity was killing him. He got up and took the book and sat back down on the couch. He read every page. He blushed at one of the writings in it. It read, "Dear Diary, I am now in a dedicated relationship with Jeff. He is the greatest guy I know. I just feel like when i'm with him, I forget all the stupid things the world does to me. I feel like he is my luck charm and I love him sooo much." He just whistled and put the diary back where it was and went back to watching TV with a smile.
Eyeless Jack:
He was just eating a kidney when he saw your diary on the kitchen counter. He looked behind him and grabbed the diary and started to read fast, just in case you decided to enter the kitchen. He grumbled at some of the photos you put in the diary of him sleeping without his mask on. Yet, he blushed at when you called him 'sexy' when he sleeps. He set the book down and just continued to eat his kidney.
Masky:
"Hey ____, can I read your diary?" Masky asked. You were too busy listening to music and doing work on the computer to understand so you just waved him on. Masky found your diary and read each page. He laughed at one writing you did. It read, "Well, today might have been a bad day. I fell down some stairs, L.J hit me in the face with a pie that he bought and Slender keeps scaring me when I walk through the hallways!" He just returned the book back to its original space and walked out of the room.
Hoodie:
Hoodie was super curious about your diary when he learned that you had one hidden somewhere. He knew you'd hide it somewhere he would never check so he checked everywhere. "Aha! Found it!" He cried out. He sat on the bed and began to read each page and each detail. Most of it was little songs you conjured up or drawings of him and you together. He smiled at this and returned the book to its original hiding spot.
Ticci Toby:
He was eating pancakes while reading your diary that he found in the living room. He smiled at this one page. It read, "Pancakes are so awesome. They would totally beat waffles in a world war. Haha all the mini pancakes would be so happy. :3 Man i'm so crazy sometimes." "This is why I love you so much ____." He laughed.
Ben Drowned:
Ben found your diary weeks ago and still couldn't stop reading each new little writing you wrote. Most of them were just little quotes you find and make up yourself. He couldn't stop reading because he wanted to know everything about you no matter how scary. He did find out that you are afraid of snakes though.
YOU ARE READING
Creepypasta Boyfriend Scenarios
FanfictionIncludes: Slenderman, Jeff the Killer, Eyeless Jack, Masky, Hoodie, Ticci Toby, BEN Drowned and Homicidal Liu.