Creepypasta Boyfriend Scenarios

When he scares you

Requested by the lovely @IzzyDerpish

Key: (y/n) : Your name (y/f/s) : Your favorite song (y/f/f) : Your favorite food (y/f/c) : Your favorite cheesecake (Y-Y-Y/N) : Toby's stutter :) (h/l) : Hair Length (h/c) : Hair Color

Slenderman:

You had been cleaning around Slender Mansion and had finished mopping a spot and picked up your bucket to move to the next dirty spot. Suddenly you heard static and assumed Slender had appeared behind you. You turned around to indeed, find Slender, but Slender was extremely upset and his tendrils flailing wildly and his iconic scream reached your ears. You screamed and dropped your bucket, spilling the cleaning solution everywhere and splashing some onto your clothes. "SLENDER!" You shouted at him. "Sorry, (Y/N)! I didn't mean to scare you! I was just looking for Jeff. He splattered my office with black paint!" Slender said, obviously angry at Jeff. You huffed in response, stomping off to go change and clean up all the spilled cleaning solution. Slenderman followed you, apologizing to you the whole time.

Jeff the Killer:

You had been listening to (y/f/s) when you heard rustling around in the background. You shrugged it off as just being the pastas messing around. You heard some low mumbles and loud mumbles, but they disappeared as soon as they were heard. You looked up, but no one was there. You started to get goosebumps, but knew you couldn't get freaked out in a place full of murderers. Then you felt the cold sharp steel of a blade hit your neck and you jumped in fear. You ripped your headphones off and turned around to see Jeff laughing. "Did you see yourself, (Y/N)?!" He laughed loudly, filling the mansion with his laughter. You growled and started to get extremely upset. "You jumped like 5 feet into the air! Hah!" He finished his sentence and continued laughing. "JEFFREY! YOU ARE SLEEPING DOWNSTAIRS TONIGHT!" You shouted and walked off in fury. His eyes widened (if this is even possible) and ran off to you shouting apologies and begging for forgiveness. You wouldn't have any of his crap and a disappointed Jeff ended up sleeping on the couch that night with the rest of the pastas laughing at his misfortune.

Eyeless Jack:

You were sleeping peacefully, dreaming of a beautiful sunset and the stars in the sky, when Jack had to mess it up. As you were sleeping, Jack saw your sleeping frame and smirked. He came up with a devilish idea, he wanted to scare you while you slept. He grabbed his scalpel from his hoodie and quietly walked up to your bed and climbed on top of you. He slowly made an incision on your side. You woke up screaming and found Jack on top of you, holding his scalpel. "Jack! What the hell?!" You screamed, holding your now bleeding side. He started laughing, only to be punched in his side by an angry (Y/N). "I'm sorry! Come on, I'll go get you patched up." He said, taking your hand and leading you to the bathroom to go get your side patched up. "I forgive you." You mumbled loud enough for him to hear and he gave a huge sigh of relief, thankful that you didn't do anything to his kidney collection or anything like that...Or so he thought.

Masky:

You were walking around the kitchen, checking all cabinets and doors for food. Then you stumbled upon something magical. A tinfoil wrapped plate. It looked like a wrapped piece of cheesecake and your mouth watered. Your stomach growled, but your face fell at the sight of a piece of paper saying "MASKY'S.. HANDS OFF!!" Your mind started racing. 'Would he even notice if I took a bite?' 'I doubt it, it's such a nice slice. He wouldn't mind just ONE bite.' 'It looks so good, I have to take a bite.' All those thoughts ran through your mind. You slowly took the forbidden cheesecake out of the fridge and placed it onto the table. You unwrapped it's coverings and grabbed a clean fork. It was a (y/f/c) cheesecake. Your mouth watered even more and you slowly plunged your all too clean fork into the lovely cheesecake, only to have a spider like creature fling out of the cheesecake and towards your face. You screamed and crouched down onto the floor. You looked behind you to the 'spider like creature' only to find a robotic spider with wheels attached to the bottom. "MASSSSKKYYYYY!" You screamed, loud enough for the whole mansion to hear. Masky laughed a little, and revealed himself from behind the wall outside the kitchen. "Sorry, (Y/N), just had to make sure you knew not to touch my cheesecake!" He laughed, eventually giving up after your pouting session and sharing the cheesecake with you.