It had been a few hours and the pair had caught up.
Dean told about everything from high school to now. Castiel talked about how Gabriel left and how Jimmy had settled down and had a daughter.
"So Cas, did you settle down? Find yourself a pretty lady and knock her up?" Dean asked.
Cas rubbed the back of his neck. "It's complicated. I haven't had feelings for someone since high school.." He awkwardly admitted.
"Wow. So who was your school girl crush?" Dean smirked mischievously.
A lump formed in Cas's throat. "Was it Benny? Oo, maybe Garth." Dean teased. Cas didn't have the voice to tell him it was him.
"Cat got your tongue, buddy?" At that moment, there was a knock at the door.
Cas found it the perfect excuse to not answer the question and got up to answer the door. He was not expecting to see the face of a tall man.
"Sammy! Seems you came to get my wounded ass after all." Dean grinned. He had called the younger Winchester earlier to let him know he was still alive.
Sam took quick notice to the bright, blue eyes and pulled Cas into a hug. After, Cas let him in and he sat beside his brother.
"You came just in time for me to try to get his high school crush out of him." Dean chuckled. Sam swallowed.
He was one of the only two people who was trusted with that secret, besides Jimmy.
Snapping back to reality, he fake replied, "Yeah, who was it Cas?" In his mind, Castiel wanted to question the reply but didn't.
"Why'd the peanut gallery go silent?" Dean asked. The others both looked at him so he could think about his question.
"What? It wasn't me, was it?" Cas started to slowly nod, making him swallow hard.
"I would have told you at homecoming dance if hadn't left and if you would have accepted my invitation.." Cas explained.
"Right, of course.." Dean sighed and looked over at Sam. "We're you in on this too?"
"Yeah." The giant replied. "Is there anybody else I need to know was in on this whole secret?"
"Jimmy was." "Where is Jimmy anyway?" Sam asked.
"He lives in Pontiac, Illinois with his family." "He has a family?" "Yes, a wife and a daughter named Claire."
"Shut up Chatty Cathys. I think that's enough chit chat for me for one day." Dean interuppted, getting up and walking out.
"I guess the whole 'high school crush secret' was too much for him to handle." Sam shrugged. "Possibly. Knowing Dean, he is probably mad over the fact that I never told him." Cas sighed.
"Well, thanks for the hospitality, Cas." "You're welcome, Sam." "See you around?" "Yes."
Castiel closed the door behind Sam felt his stomach drop.
