I Will Win Her Heart 2 [Eren X Reader X Armin X Levi]

Chapter 4

"Did you really have to do that Levi!?" You said to him, sitting on the couch, everyone else still standing around Eren holding the hat.

Eren and Armin must have been in another room because you did not see them when the person opened the door to the closet.

"(y/n), Levi, get back over here." Eren said. "Your name gets put back in and you get another turn, we're doing 10 turns, or until everyone goes once." You blushed at the thought of going again.

Eren put your name back in and you hoped you weren't called again. "Jean and Marco!" Eren said. He pushed them into the closet. "Have fun you two!" Eren yelled. 

After 3 minutes of sitting and listening, you heard what sounded like... kissing!? You opened the door to see Jean making out with Marco. You snapped a picture and burst out laughing as Jean and Marco's faces turned, as red as tomatoes. "I knew you two liked each other!" You shouted in between laughs.

"Shut it, will you!?" Jean said, storming out of the closet, Marco following.

Two more turns went by, Sasha and Connie, nothing but almost a kiss, they were about an inch apart, and Mikasa and Hanji, nothing happened between them, obviously.

It was the 6th turn and it was you and Armin. You could hear Eren mutter under his breath "C'mon, why am I the one to not get a damn chance with her!?" Before he pushed you two into the closet.

You could hear Armin breathing heavily, you turn to face him right next to you, he looks into your (e/c) eyes, still sparkling with only the little light visible in the dim closet. 

"Was there something you wanted to ask me?" He asks, not bringing his eyes away from yours. "So... Hows it going...?" You ask him. "Good, I guess..." He mutters, unfolding his knees from his chest. 

He turns back over to you and puts his hand on your cheek as your face starts to get a deeper shade of pink. "So damn beautiful..." He said as he leaned in, pressing his lips ever so gently into yours. You kissed back, wanting to share everything with him.

He pulled back after a good few seconds of kissing "Armin..." You said slightly, your eyes starting to water. "I just..." You said quietly.

You wanted a kiss from him again, it seemed to take all of your troubles away and make everything around you disappear to where it was only the two of you.

He leaned in and went for another kiss. The door opened. You pulled away before anyone could see anything. Your face still a little pink.

You came out of the closet and Eren put your names back into the bowl. More turns went by.

Eren and Sasha, nothing. You and Jean, Jean tries to kiss you again and you push him off of you and kick him in the stomach. Jean and Mikasa, Jean tried to kiss Mikasa and came out with a black eye.

"(y/n)..." Eren says again. "And me!" He shouts. He goes into the closet, Mikasa closing the closet door. 

Eren sits next to you and you start to poke him. He pushes you over playfully and you get back up. You put your head on his shoulder and close your eyes. 

He kisses your forehead and you look at him. He leans in for a kiss and he kisses you. You kiss back. Eren's kisses were a little more rough than Armin's, but not by alot.

He pushes you over and starts to kiss your cheek. You blush at the act and then he kisses you again. You could hear footsteps come to open the door. You sat back up, making yourselves look like nothing important happened.

You had been caught, and almost been caught again. You didn't want to get caught this time. The door opened and you smiled to the sight of Mikasa. She let you two out and you all went to go eat. You all decided to eat at Bellinis.

You all ate and went back to Eren's house. It was late so you decided to spend the night at Eren's house.