Omaha Horror Story

Part 2

Y/N POV

"Dinners ready!" Stass called from the kitchen. Everyone gathered round the table.

"Why are there two empty seats?" I frowned.

"Pretty sure Madison's taking a nap. The door was shut, I went to check on her." Gilinsky said.

"She definitely wanted to get out of cooking." Emily laughed.

"What about John?" Nate asked.

"He seemed fascinated with the lake, he might've went for a walk." Kenny said.

"But it's so dark." Johnson said.

"Johns a big boy, I'm sure he's fine. Let's eat before everything gets cold." I said.

Dinner was enjoyable, especially with a few glasses of wine. Before we knew it, we were all tipsy.

Kenny and Emily went off to their room to have some alone time. The rest of us, gathered in the living room to play some truth or dare.

"I wanna start!!" Gilinsky called out like a little kid.

"Wow G, I'm surprised you're hanging with your friends and not your girlfriend." Johnson teased.

"Well considering she's most like asleep, you guys are the better option." Gilinsky replied.

"Hmmm okay, Nate truth or dare." Gilinsky asked.

"Truth." Nate said confidently, taking a hit of the blunt.

"Is it true that you and Stass fucked before she got with Sam."

I nearly choked on my fifth glass of wine, or sixth... I lost count. Sam's jaw clenched, as both Stass and Nate turned red.

"That would be true." Nate said.

"I KNEW IT." Johnson called out like this was a game of yatzi.

"It was a long time ago babe." Stass said to Sam.

"Okay, um truth or dare Y/N." Nate said trying to change the subject.

"Dare." I said trying to spice things up.

"I dare you to go..." Nate began until he was interrupted by a loud boom of thunder.

"Looks like the storms here. We might lose power, candles and matches are in the cabinets... Pretty sure we have enough firewood though." Sam said.

"Great the last thing we need is a storm stranding us here with Lester." Stass said rolling her eyes as she glanced down at her perfect nails.

"It's really weird that John isn't back yet." Nate said.

"Aw are you worried about your boyfriend...maybe Lester took him." I joked.

"Not funny Y/N. Nate's right, where the hell is John." Johnson said.

"I'm gonna wake up Madison. I'm surprised she didn't come down yet." Gilinsky said getting up from his spot on the sofa and headed upstairs.

"Maybe John left." Stass suggested, taking a sip of wine as Sam got up and walked towards the front door.

"He wouldn't just leave like that."I added.

"Maybe he did, my cars gone." Sam said.

"What?! How'd he even get your keys, and why would he leave?" Nate said, looking visibly upset.

"Who knows man... Try calling him." Johnson said as Nate pulled out his phone.

"Of course, no fucking service." Nate said throwing his phone down.