"It's a shame that Brian and Jade didn't want to play because I would have dared them to kiss" Elise said.
We played a few rounds without much interesting happening. "Riley, truth or dare?" Amy asked.
I gave it some thought "Truth" I answered.
"Okay... Why didn't you want Jade and Brian to play?" She questioned.
Usually I would consider it a lame question but under this circumstance I suppose it wasn't. But I did lie "As Brian said it isn't a smart idea to play truth or dare with teachers" I shrugged.
"You've never had an objection to Jade playing before" Kate commented.
Luke leaned over to me "It's not like I would have dared you to kiss Brian again". I guess he said it a little too loud because everyone immediately looked at us quizzically.
"What does Luke mean by again?" Sam inquired.
I shook my head "It's my turn to ask the questions" I changed the subject.
"Fine but we're not going to drop this" Elise said.
We played a few more rounds and every time I got to choose between truth or dare I would pick dare so that they couldn't ask me even though I knew I'd have to tell them soon enough.
"Dare" I answered to Kate.
"I dare you to tell the truth" She smirked.
"You can't do that" Amy stated, we had made a rule you can't dare someone to tell the truth.
"OK, well I dare you to choose truth on your next go" Kate said. Could she do that? I guess it was a loop hole.
Of course I was asked truth or dare after two more go's. " What did Luke mean when he said that he wouldn't dare you to kiss Brian again? And when on earth did it happen?" Sam demanded
Even though it was two questions they went hand in hand. "You all know about it you just didn't know the guy was Brian, and neither did I until our first detention with him when he showed us that picture of him and Caleb where he had red hair" I explained.
"Do you mean that guy Luke dared you to kiss in a mall two years ago was Brian?!" Kate yelled, catching on immediately.
"Shush!" I said throwing a cushion at her. She face-palmed herself and gave an apologetic smile "But yes. I just didn't want you guys to worry so I didn't tell you but truth is I think I really like Brian. I know it's wrong but I haven't been able to keep him off my mind. Now that I know him I realise the real him is far better than the version I had imagined".
"I take back what I said about Brian and Jade. I totally ship you and Brian" Elise announced.
"Are you sure this isn't fate?" Sam asked.
"That's what I think, she won't listen though" Luke smirked.
"Does Brian know about you being the girl from the mall?" Amy asked.
"Are you kidding!? No he doesn't and you better not tell him" I yelled. "Plus I don't even know if he remembers the kiss".
"Judging by how you described that kiss I'm guessing it'd be pretty hard for both parties to forget. Now that I think about it he does seem to treat you specially" Elise grinned.
"I also tried to tell her that" Luke said.
"Brian and Riley sitting in a tree-" Kate began to sing, the others all joint in.
"Stop, nothing will happen between us. It can't he's my teacher" I reminded them.
They fell silent and stayed quiet for some time. "Well your secret's safe with us" Sam promised.
"Good now let's just drop the subject" I demanded.
I could tell they all still had questions but they obeyed anyway.
"Hey guys, come down stairs for a Tim Burton marathon!" Jade called out. So we done just that.
YOU ARE READING
This Feels So Right~~~ Old version
RomanceThis is the old version of this story, you can find a newer version on my profile if you want to read that one instead. However this is still available to read too. ----------------------------- A dared kiss at the mall leaves two strangers Brian...