Waffles and Killers (Ticci Toby x Reader)

Valentine's Day Special

(Reader's PoV)

It's been three years since our first date. No, I'm still a virgin if you were wondering. Today's Valentine's Day. A huge day for couples. This year I decided to make him waffles and pancakes in a pile together and give him a watch with a subscription which said (initials) x TR.

I woke up early and bounded downstairs to make the fluffy foods of goodness. Once I finished that I got his gift and put both on the table. The cute thing about his watch was that it was shaped like a pancake and dribbles of syrup told the time and the box it was in looked like a miniature waffle. I walked over and made myself a pile of pancakes and waffles then went upstairs to wake up Toby.

I knocked on his door continuously until he woke up. He opened his door looking mad until he saw it was me.

"Hey, Waffle," Toby replied.

I smiled and stated, "Good morning, Goggles." I called him goggles because he almost always wore his goggles. Even when sleeping.

"Why are you waking me up so early?" he asked.

"Because I made your favorite," I answered. His eyes lit up with excitement and he bolted downstairs. I chased after him close on his heels because I knew if I wasn't there in time my food would also be gone. When we reached the kitchen he ran over to his plate and started to put butter and syrup on his pile. After that was on he started eating them like there was no tomorrow.

I sat down and put (what you out on waffles and pancakes for I put on jam and butter') and started eating. He then noticed the box the watch was in after he finished his food.

"Is this for me?" Toby asked. I laughed and nodded my head. He opened the present and his eyes lit up as soon as he saw it.

"Thank you so much! I love it," he cheered. He put the watch on and then bolted upstairs. I stayed seated and finished eating. When he came back down, he had a bag with him. He handed me the bag and nodded me to open it.

I opened the bag and inside was a light tan nightgown with little waffles on it. There was also a card in it which said 'For my Waffle.' I blushed at it for it was a little short.

"I was hoping you would wear it tonight," Toby stated. I nodded my head in agreement. Ever since a year ago we got permission from Slenderman to share a room together. He wouldn't allow us to until we've been dating for two years. Over that time I've also become great friends with Psychotic Wolf and was able to make her more sociable.

Speaking of Wolf, she ran into the room and hid behind me holding my shoulders like I was a shield. Soon after Ben came running in soaked to the bone with water.

"Wolf, you know I can see you and when you step away from her your going to visit an old friend," Ben threatened. Her eyes widened in surprise that he would take her to visit an old friend. She thought for a moment on who it could be and when she realized who it was raised her pointer finger in the air dramatically then put her hand back on my shoulder.

"You know I shouldn't visit him. You remember the first and last time I visited him. Besides after that event you wouldn't let me see him so why now?" Wolf questioned.

"I think you deserve a treat," Ben replied creepily. I felt Wolf shiver behind me. I thought for a few moments on who it could be and them realized it must be D.L. She never did tell me who the initial were for.

"Are you talking about D.L?" I asked.

"Ya. She didn't tell you about him. You see Dark Link was her first kiss and her second 'human' friend," Ben explained. "I'm actually surprised they didn't get farther than they did that meeting."