Creepypasta Boyfriend Scenarios

Valentine Surprise

It had been a few months from the kiss you had shared under the mistletoe, you couldn't help but feel a bit on edge as both of you had been avoiding each other. It wasn't flat out avoid but the awkward shy type of avoid, like the cheesy movie thing of touching hands you would jerk them back and blush fluffy shit. But it seems he was finally getting tired of it as he had asked you to meet him... Alone.

Slender-

When he had asked you to come to his office within his house hold, you never expected to find that you were the only ones there; human nature put you on edge. "(Y/n), please shut the door and take a seat." Slender requested when you arrived. With shaky movements you shut the door like he asked then took a seat across from him. Nervous thoughts quickly began to eat you from the inside 'what if he didn't like the kiss? What if he's tired of me and wants to remove the only human that knows where they live?' You were about to say something to stop him from removing you from the house when you let a startled squeak out, finding slender's mouth torn open and kissing you. You face quickly lit up in bright red and remained that way until he pulled back to let you have air.

"S-slender?"

"Happy Valentines Day My dear," he chuckles some before kissing you yet again. "(Y/N) be mine forever..." He requests quietly to which you respond with your own kiss to him. You were finally together...

Jeff-

Jeff had made the odd request of you to meet him in an alleyway, course being human you were scared out of your mind. Maybe becoming friends with the crazy killer wasn't a smart idea, or heading into the alleyway. You quickly picked up your pace when you noticed you were being followed by two men who were grinning at the sight of you so scared. "Hey doll, where you going?" One asked as he grabbed your shirt and pulled you to them.

"To meet my friend who will be very unhappy with you if you hurt me." You squeaked back as the other grabbed your ass then. In panic you yelled out "Jeff!" That's when the first man slapped you up side the head, making your ears ring as you stumbled around until you met what you thought was a wall.

"Don't you know it's rude to treat as lady like that?" Jeff voice said as a pair of arms embraced you lightly and helped you sit down. "I think it's best you go to sleep now." He growled before he killed the men, returning to your side and crouched before you. "Some boyfriend I'll be huh?" You only stared at him in surprise then before giggling and nodding, pecking his cheek. Smiling at you Jeff held you to him. "Happy Valentine's Day too."

Ben-

Recently you had gotten a new game, halo 5(if you don't like it to bad XD) and had been playing it often, so when a Master Chief stepped out of your tv screen; let's just say you screamed bloody murder before fainting. When you woke up you found Ben staring down at you in panic. "Jeez I didn't think I'd scare you that much." He says before you shoved him back, pouting at him. Ben grins sheepishly as you noticed the Master Chief still standing there with a sign now in his hands. 'Happy Valentine's Day'. You couldn't help but gush at the gift from Ben and proceeded to tackle hug the poor pasta. Ben yelped surprised when you did but giggled with you and kisses your forehead. "So does this mean you'll be mine?" He asks cheekily as you rolled your eyes but nodded. "Score one for the boss!" He cheered as he fist pumped the air.

(Sorry his is so short. I warned you from the start.

Masky and Hoodie(this is just me being lazy so yeah.)-

When the two pastas had asked the two of you to come(yeah there's 2 readers here and you now know each other :3) you didn't think much of it. I mean it wasn't that odd for them to ask you to come out with them, after all the two were partners under slender. The pair had worked together in getting you to come down to the cheesecake cafe, to which it was reserved for a 'private event'. Upon arrival you were lead to a table where the pastas came cheesly(see what I did there?) out dressed in little waiter outfits. The pair treated you both to a fancy time with much cheesecake until the very end when you were going to go. They stopped you both and shyly held your hands as they muttered their "happy Valentine's Day." To you. With a smile to your friend you embraced your pasta and whispered in his ear. "Can't wait to see how you top this next year, oh boyfriend~"

Rake-

(F/m) favorite meal

You had gotten use to rake asking you to come alone, I mean he does kinda have those claws and such, so when he asked you this time you didn't think much of it. Needless to say you were surprised when you found him in the forest with a tree stump set up for a dinner for two, he even had tried to put a tie on for you. He quickly helped you sit on the stump he had for a seat and pushed you to the 'table'. He had gotten slender to make (f/m) for you and had his normal human meal for himself. Things were peaceful between you two as the night went on, after dinner rake took you to the pasta house before he climbed onto the roof with you hanging onto his back for dear life. "You can let go now." He says once he had gotten to the top and away from the ledge so you didn't fall. Carefully pealing yourself from his back you gasped in awe as you couldn't see anything but the forest and the sky above. Humming some rake put his chin on your shoulder and nuzzled your cheek"happy Valentine's Day." He then wrapped his arms around your waist and held you to him. "I'll keep you safe, as your boyfriend I promise."

Happy Valentine's Day my lovelies