Remember Love (Sam Winchester x Reader)

{7}

It had been three weeks since Haley had gone missing, and you worried about her every day. You had been using what you learned from hunting to look for her since she disappeared. But, so far, you hadn't found anything, and it was driving you crazy.

You were in the middle of doing some research when you heard a knock on your door. You went to open it, and when you did, you found none other than Sam and Dean Winchester standing there.

Your heart skipped a beat at the sight of Sam. All of the feelings you thought you had gotten over, came rushing back. You all just stood there staring at each other for what seemed like forever. Finally, Sam broke the silence by saying, "Hi Y/N, it's good to see you." You were still speechless, so all you did was move out of the doorway and gestured for the two boys to come in.

They went inside your apartment and Sam sat down on the couch. "Can I get you anything?" you asked them, still not sure what to say.

"Do you have a beer?" Dean asked. You nodded and grabbed a beer from the fridge and tossed it to Dean. "What are you guys doing here?" you asked.

"Visiting an old friend," Sam replied. You gave him a slight smile before Sam added, "And we heard about your roommate Haley Burton."

You nodded and said, "Yeah. I've been doing research all week." "Research?" Sam asked. "Clearly this isn't a regular missing person's case. I've been trying to figure out what monster took her," you replied.

"How long has Haley been missing?" Sam asked. "About three weeks," you replied sadly. Sam let out a small sigh and came over and hugged you.

"I'm so sorry Y/N," Sam said. You hugged him back before letting go of him and saying, "It's okay, let's just find Haley." You walked into your kitchen, to try and get away from Sam.

All of the feelings that Haley had helped you get over had just come rushing back to you, and you were overwhelmed. You had just gotten used to the fact that you weren't going to see Sam. Now, here he was.

"I'm sorry about the way I left," Sam said, joining you in the kitchen. "It's fine," you replied. "No, it's not," Sam replied.

"Sam, you had just found out your dad was missing, and then Jess had just died. You had a lot to deal with," you told Sam. "Yeah, but still, Y/N, you were my best friend," Sam said.

You let out a small sigh at Sam's words. "Best friend," you repeated in your head. Were you only ever going to be Sam's best friend? Could you ever be more than that?

You were so in love with Sam, but he only thought of you as a friend. "It's okay Sam, I forgive you," you told him. Sam gave you a small smile and said, "Thanks."

You nodded and walked back to Dean who was on your computer. "Did you find anything?" you asked Dean. "Yeah, actually. I could be demons that took Haley," Dean replied.

"Why do you say that?" you asked. "Because there have been several missing people in the last few weeks, and at each of the cases, there have been traces of sulfur," Dean explained. "But, I searched the apartment, there's no sulfur," you replied. "Not here, but at the diner, there was," Dean responded.

"Oh," you said. You hadn't been to the diner since Haley went missing, but now everything made sense. "Y/N, we can go get Haley by ourselves, if you don't want to," Sam said. "No, I want to," you replied. You opened your closet and pulled out holy water.

"Let's go," you told the boys. "You're going with just holy water?" Dean asked. "Well I assume you boys have better weapons, so yes, I'm going with just holy water. Now, let's go," you answered.

You grabbed your keys and left the apartment. "Y/N, we don't even know where the demons are," Sam said. "I do," you told them. "Just follow me," you instructed, getting in your car. The boys got in the Impala and followed you to an old, abandoned factory. It was the only truly abandoned building in your town, perfect for demons.

You were the first one to get to the doors of the factory. You pushed the door, and surprisingly, it was unlocked. It opened with a small creak and you peered inside the dark building.

Sam and Dean soon joined your side. "Alright, Y/N, you go with Sam, and I will go the other way to look for Haley," Dean said. You nodded and you and Sam went one way while Dean went the other way.

It didn't take long for you two to find Haley. She was tied to a chair along with three other girls. Blood covered Haley, and Haley's head was titled as she was unconscious.

"Haley?" you asked going out towards her. "Y/N, wait," Sam said, but you ignored him. You went over to Haley and gently shook her. She woke up with a gasp, and you couldn't help but smile.

"Are you okay, Haley?" you asked. Haley nodded her head and then her eyes widened. You looked behind you and there was a demon.

Right before the demon hit you, Sam came up behind it and stabbed it. A light glowed from the demon before it dropped dead. You and Sam exchanged looks before you turned back to Haley. You untied her while Sam checked the other girls' pulses. "Are any of them alive?" you asked Sam. Sam shook his head no, and you let out a small, sad sigh.

You helped Haley up and led her to your car. Sam followed you and Dean came out soon after. "Let's go celebrate," Haley suggested.

You let out a small chuckle and said, "Haley, you were just kidnapped by demons, and you want to go celebrate?" Haley laughed and said, "Yeah, I'm fine. They barely touched me before you guys showed up."

Haley grabbed a small cloth from your car and wiped the blood off of her face and arms off. "See? I'm perfectly okay, but I could really use a drink," Haley said.

You let out a quiet laugh and said, "Fine, we'll go to a bar," you told Haley. Haley got a bright smile on her face and hugged you.

You turned to Sam and Dean and asked, "Do you guys want to come?" Dean and Sam shared looks before agreeing with smiles.