After a while of thinking, Doll Maker is ready to tell Luke his decision. Luke is now playing his electric guitar while Oliver is finish taking care of Marsjall with the help of Hoodie. Doll Maker came over and he look at Luke.
"Luke can I tell you something?" Doll Maker asked
"Well ok." Luke said
Doll Maker then went to the living room as Oliver is curious and went over to listen to the conversation.
"Yes?" Luke asked
"I don't think this relationship will work out between us. You hurt me twice and I don't want to be hurt the third time. I think it would be better if we just go our separate ways. We can still be friends and you can still be apart of Oliver's life." Doll Maker said
Luke felt sad as he then take off the ring off of his finger and ran out of the mansion as Oliver is in shock as he tear up that his fathers aren't together anymore. Slender sees this and bring Oliver to his office and he close the door and look at Oliver.
"Oliver in life, people love each other and when they been with each other for so long well.. They'll did something they are not proud of. The lover doesn't feel that the other lover doesn't give enough attention." Slender said
Oliver nodded in understanding as Slender then look at him.
"Just don't do the same thing like your dad did." Slender said
Oliver begin to feel worried about that and Slender look at him.
"Don't worry about it Oliver. Just keep being happy with LS and if you feel that you are unattractive to LS, we'll talk." Slender said
"Alright thank you." Oliver said
Oliver came out and begin to play some video games with LS, Andy, Ian and Nick. As for Luke, he went to the carnival with tears down his face and he knock on the door as Andrew answered
"Luke hey. What's wrong?" Andrew asked
"My relationship with Doll Maker is over. I cheated on him with Offender and now he told me that it's over for him." Luke cried
"Oh my that's awful. I'm sure everything will be ok." Andrew said
Andrew allow Luke inside and he hugged him as Luke cried on Andrew's shoulder. Skittles begin to whimper as Andrew pet him. It is now night and everyone already gotten ready for bed as Luke felt depressed and wanted to end all the pain. He went to the candy storage and take the poison candy as he got a handful and went in another room to take it. LJ came and he notice that his poison candy are missing and he went over to look for it. Luke then unwrapped the candies and close his eyes as he is about to take it until LJ notice Luke is going to take the poison candy and took it away.
"You can't die again Luke. This will be the third time." LJ said
"You don't understand because your marriage isn't like mine!" Luke cried
"I disagree Luke. I have my ups and downs with my marriage with SB. You see when you die from that horrible car crash, I did something I wasn't proud of. I drank alcohol and hit her and my kids out of anger and I made my mistakes for doing that." LJ said
"What can I do huh? You won't understand the pain I'm feeling now!" Luke said while crying
"Just move on without Doll Maker even if it hurts." LJ said
"I-I'll try." Luke sniffled
LJ then take the poison candy and hug Luke for comfort and Luke then went in Andrew's room as he cried himself to sleep. He is now depressed that his relationship with Doll Maker is now over
