Background ~ Andy throw a birthday party for you and brought you a necklace
The night was nearly over, all the guests had left, Pete was happily chatting with Patrick, Brendon and Joe were having a beer, Mhea and Andy were talking about only God knew what and Mikey, Gerard and Frank were just having a chat together.
You, on the other hand, were standing on the balcony, looking up at the stars; it had been a wonderful night, you'd had lot of fun and everyone had been so nice with you that you literally couldn't help smiling while playing with your new necklace that Andy brought you.
"Did you enjoy your birthday party?"
You turned around as that unmistakable American accent came to your ears and Andy was there, leaning against the wall with a beautiful grin on his face.
You nodded in response and tried to take a step in his direction, but he immediately reached you with his super strong arms and soon his hands were on your hips.
"So, did you make your wish?"
He asked while looking into your eyes and you giggled, biting your lower lip, he was so damn handsome that your legs were barely shaking because of the small distance between your faces.
"Of course I did"
"And, what did you wish for?"
His fingers were now on your cheek and you blushed, looking down at your feet. He was your only birthday wish.
"I can't tell you or it won't come true"
You said while playing with your hands and he lifted your face, reducing the gap between your mouths.
"Well, I think this might be an exception"
He slightly smiled, moving a lock of your hair behind your ear and you swallowed, your throat was incredibly dry while you were trying to find the words to say.
"I can only tell you that it's nearly granted" You whispered while looking at his lips and he finally kissed you, cupping your face with his big hands. Your heart skipped a beat while your eyes were closed, you put your hands on his shoulders and deepened the kiss.
"Wow"The two of you murmured at the same time as you pulled away, but Andy quickly picked your lips, anxious to taste you again.
There was something different in your eyes, suddenly kisses were no longer enough, you wanted to feel him, you wanted to love him.
Your cheeks turned red because of your thoughts and you wished you could have disappeared, since you knew he understood you. After all, things had always been that way between you and Andy, you understood each other, even without speaking.
He stared at you for a moment, then he picked you up and, a second later, you found yourself in the hallway of the beedroom floor; you hid your face in the crook of his neck, painfully embarassed, as he giggled while opening his bedroom door.
"Will you please stay with me tonight?"
He asked before two fingers were placed under your chin and you gave him a shy smile.
"I'd love to"
Andy smiled back as he closed the door behind him, you looked at each other for a while, until he held you by your waist.
"How about a kiss?"
He whispered in your ear causing you to shiver, you were melting into his arms while he placed his lips on yours once more, but when he broke the kiss, trying to grab some air, your anxiety come out and he noticed it, indeed he started to caress your cheeck with a worried face.
"Y/N, I don't... I don't want you to feel pressured into anything. We can always lay here and cuddle all-"
You stopped him by shaking your head.
"No, I want this, I want you. It's just that... I've never done this before"
"I know that, and I'm glad you want me to be your first, but if you don't feel ready tonight, I will wait"
You sweetly kissed him, putting your hands through his white hair, you could feel your heart pumping in your ears.
"Make love to me"
You murmured while looking in his beautiful blue eyes (I'm not sure what colour his eyes are sorry forgive me 😂) and he smiled, lifting you in order to reach his bed.
You slowly undressed each other in between kisses, until your bodies were covered with nothing but your underwear, Andy took a moment to look at your curves and you covered your face with your hands.
"Hey, you have nothing to feel embarassed or ashamed of, I mean, you're gorgerous and I'm just so lucky"
You blushed at those words and he started to stroke your hips, placing soft kisses on your neck and chest, still half covered with your bra, but he took it off soon after.
"I think we can keep this one"
He said with a gentle smile, while pointing at the pendant he had given you and you kissed his mouth before he lowered his head onto your body again. You held his shoulders, moaning in pleasuere as his mouth went down your stomach, Andy looked up at you, silently asking for your permission, and when you nodded he took off your panties, kissing your legs in the process. Your body was now shaking with agitation, so he put a hand through your hair and slowly kissed you, but as you felt his fingers teasing the soft skin of your thigh, your legs instinctively squeezed.
"Y/N, you need to relax, okay? Just look in to my eyes, trust me"
You bitted your lower lip never breaking the eye-contact, even when he started to slowly touch you, causing you to whimper, but you gasped in pain as one of his fingers slid into you and he kissed your forehead, whispering sweet nothings to your ear. Once he felt you were wet enough, he removed his boxers and took a condom from his closet, you cheeks were red again, while you were staring at his beautiful body. Andy crawled on top of you, placing himself between your thighs and held you closer, eager to feel your skin against his.
"But I didn't-"
You tried to say, but he stopped you with a quick kiss and placed one of his hands on your cheek while the other was stroking your thigh and hip.
"No, babe, tonight is all about you"
He tenderly brushed your hair from your face and rested his forehead on yours, never breaking the eye-contact.
"Are you sure about this, y/n?"
You nodded completely sure about what you were doing and took a deep breath, in order to banish your anxiety, he smiply kissed the tip of your nose before he placed himself at your entrance.
"Please, tell me if I hurt you, Baby"
Andy slowly pushed his tip into you and you cried out at that first invasion, your nails scratched his back and your eyes filled with tears.
"Do you want me to pull out? Babe, please, I don't want to hurt you"
You swallowed and stopped holding your breath.
"N-no, I'm fine, Andy. Keep going"
He kissed you, holding one of your hands and he went all the way in, trying to hold you down with his other hand as you were now attempting to push him away because of the sharp pain.
You stifled a cry against his shoulders and tears started to roll down your face, it hurted so much you could barely breathe.
"God, I'm so sorry" his voice craked "if I only could I'd take away the pain, just for you, my love"
He started to kiss your lips and cheeks, desperately trying to distract you from the pain, his fingers gently wiped away your tears.
"Shh, don't cry, I'm here with you, princess"
He waited for you to adjuste, softly kissing your skin and whispering sweet promises against your lips, then you gave him a nod and he slowly started to move, finally making love to you.
Your bodiingers laced, heads on shoulders, legs entwined and you felt so complete. His groans increased after a while as he was close to is climax.
"I l-love you, y/n... so fucking much"
He murmured between his moans before he reached his orgasm, hungrily pressing his mouth against yours.
Andy rested his back on the bed and drove you on his chest, slowly petting your hair and you kissed his neck, still trying to catch some air.
"Next time I'll make this feel like heaven, I promise you, baby"
He said and placed his lips on your forehead, you simply held one of his hands.
"It's okay, Andy, it's been amazing anyway, and I love you too"
He lifted your face in order to look into your eyes and slightly smiled before he kissed you one more time.
