Death of a Fan Fiction Snob

102 10 10
                                    

How Big Magic Made Me Ditch My Disdain for Fan Fiction

Lately, all people on social media want to talk about is whether Twitter is dying.

To me, it's not as strong a conversion tool as it once was for driving  eyeballs to web content, but you can't beat it for cultural conversation.

Take  publishing.

We're lucky to be alive at a time when writers whose  creative work has traditionally been ignored are speaking back to the  establishment, demanding to be heard and represented.

If you're on  Twitter, you can skulk hashtags like #weneeddiversebooks and  #publishingsowhite and watch in real-time as the barriers created by  racism, the patriarchy, classism, colonialism, and ableism start to fall  to the wayside.

Like  their Hollywood counterparts, agents, publishers and booksellers seem  to be grasping that there's money in creative work that includes a wider  array of human experience than that produced exclusively by white guys for white guys

Oops! This image does not follow our content guidelines. To continue publishing, please remove it or upload a different image.

Like  their Hollywood counterparts, agents, publishers and booksellers seem  to be grasping that there's money in creative work that includes a wider  array of human experience than that produced exclusively by white guys for white guys.

Yet  in the midst of all this change, people need stable rage points to  cling to lest the whole frame of reference for literary exclusion and  snobbery disappear.

Ergo: "Fan fiction is terrible."

I  mean, is there a more perfect literary scapegoat to kick as you smugly  tell yourself: "I may not be crushing this draft but by God at least I'm not writing fan fiction?"

Which basically makes fan fiction the reality TV of the literary world.

Until recently, that's exactly what I thought.

50 Shades of Think Piece

Last year, as Fifty Shades of Gray scrolled across e-readers everywhere, made truckloads of money at the box office, and spawned a thousand hot-takes, I wrote an essay  arguing that commercial fan fiction's rise is morally and creatively bankrupt (normally, I would link to my essay for your reading convenience, but Wattpad doesn't allow that).

Last year, as Fifty Shades of Gray scrolled across e-readers everywhere, made truckloads of money at the box office, and spawned a thousand hot-takes, I wrote an essay  arguing that commercial fan fiction's rise is morally and creatively bankrupt ...

Oops! This image does not follow our content guidelines. To continue publishing, please remove it or upload a different image.

I  put a lot of effort into drawing lines between "real" adaptations and  fan fiction; in reality, the pedigree for literary borrowing clearly flows all the way back to Shakespeare's pen and beyond. Adrian Fridge, whose piece I was responding to, rightly called me out for that.

Transforming Your Writing Life With WattpadWhere stories live. Discover now