My New Family (Creepypasta x Reader)

~*~Epilogue- Ticci Toby's Ending~*~

(Y/N)'s POV

It was Toby. The fireball hit him square in the chest, and he collapsed to the ground, not moving. I screamed and ran over to him. He was ashy and burned, but I hugged him anyways. He coughed and tears welled up in my eyes. "Toby! Don't go! I love you...",I said, and he tried to speak.

"I-I love you t-", he tried to say, but his eyelids drooped and his breathing stopped.

"NO! TOBY!", I screamed. Zalgo laughed and wheezed, because he was losing a lot of blood from the injuries that Slender gave him. I sobbed and hugged Toby tight to my chest.

"You... That's funny! He died... And you actually love him! He never got to say it back to you! HAHAH!!!", Zalgo laughed, and I tried to glare at him. It's hard when you are crying...

"Fuck you, Zalgo! You're such a bastard!", I screamed, and I looked at him straight in the eyes. He chuckled and smiled grotesquely at me. I shivered and scooted away. I sniffled and then I saw Slender behind Zalgo, about to stab him with his tentacle. Just as Zalgo turned around, my dad stabbed him in his head. Zalgo gasped, and then screamed an inhuman scream.

He withered away into a black mist, and then all that was left was a puddle of black blood. My dad picked up Toby gently. "Dad? Is he going to be okay?", I asked, even though I knew that he was gone. Slender examined him quickly, then all of the other pastas came into the room.

"So that's where Toby went...", Jeff said. "He wasn't helping us fight the demons... I thought he died."

"He is fucking dead! And it's all Zalgo's fault. That asshole.", I sniffled. Everyone stared at Toby's corpse. I sobbed into my hands, and Jane and Clocky consoled me. Well, they tried to.

"It's okay... He's happy... Up there.", Clocky said, pointing to the sky. Jane nodded and gave me a hug. When I thought about Toby dying and going up to Heaven, I cried even more. I missed him so fucking much... Why did he have to die? Why not me? Slender patted my shoulder, and then we all got teleported home immediately.

"(Y/N)... Child. I may be able to fix this.", Slender said, and I wiped my tears away.

"Really?", I asked.

"Really.", Slender said, and he told everyone to leave the room. Everyone did so. I watched as Slender did some weird things, then the room filled with black smoke and the smell of waffles.

"*Cough* What the fuck?!", I said, then I felt a warm hand grasp mine. As the smoke cleared, I saw a very alive, and very happy Toby Erin Rogers standing in front of me.

"I love you too.", Toby said, and he pressed his soft lips against mine. I kissed back, until Slender cleared his throat. We pulled apart, and I blushed. Toby grinned at me, then Slender opened the door. Everyone fell inside and saw Toby, alive and standing before them.

"TOBY!", they all screamed. Except Masky. He just sighed. They all went to hug him, even Masky. Wow. Talk about "enemies". They noticed Toby's hand grasping mine, and then Jane and Clocky smiled.

"I ship it!", they squealed. The boys were upset, but they soon got over it. Toby leaned towards me, and we kissed again. Sparks flew and everyone cheered.