AJ's Pov
"I'm sorry what?" I asked the the blue eyed girl again.
"I'm Olivia McAllister, look i think I got the wrong house. Sorry about it." she said and started walking towards her car.
"No, you didn't...I'm sorry but how do you know about Alice and John McAllister?" I asked and she smiled weakly.
"Alice and John are my biological parents. I was born when Alice and John were still in highschool and they gave me away for adoption. I completely understand why they did it and to be completely honest I would've done the same." she said and my breathing got heavier.
"Are you okay?" she asked and I shook out of my thoughts.
"Yeah, do mine if I take you somewhere?" I asked and she just shrugged her shoulders. I walked inside and got my keys and grabbed Michelle's helmet.
"Put this on." I say to her as we walked to my bike. I waited for her to hop on the bike but she just gave me a confused look.
"Get on." I say and she listens. "You know you'll fall off if you don't hold on." I say and she immediately wraps her arms around my stomach. I winced a little when she touched my wound but shrugged it off.
Could she be my sister. She has to be i mean she knows who my parents are and looks exactly like me.
About ten minutes later we arrived at the cemetery. "What are we doing here?" she asked and hopped off my bike. I walk towards my parents grave and waited for Olivia to catch up.
"Here is John and Alice." I say and she covers her mouth. She has tears in her eyes and I can't help but cry with her.
"What happened to them?" she asked as she dropped to her knees.
"Alice was diagnosed with breast cancer when I was nine. One day John called me and told me something was wrong with her, I asked what happened but the line went flat. Turns out he got in a car accident and..." I couldn't finish. "Sorry." I say and she looks back up at me.
"How do you know them?" she asked and got up to look at me.
"Olivia, I'm AJ McAllister your sister..."
Michelle's Pov
Me and Sky were on are way to AJ's house. Her bike wasn't there but then about five minutes later she arrives with a girl behind her.
"Who's that?" Skylar asked and I instantly got jealous.
"I don't know..." I say on the verge of tears. They both hope off the bike and AJ helped the girl out with her helmet. The hugged for while and they walked inside.
"She moved on alrea-"
"No Michelle you don't know the truth yet. Don't assume things I learned that the hard way, look Tobin and that Girl is here." Skylar says and pointed at Tobin's car that just parked in the driveway. The both of us quickly got out of the car and meet up with Tobin and Christen.
"Wait Michelle is that your car?" Tobin asked as she pointed to car next to Skylar's.
"No, but AJ is in that house with another girl." I say and Tobin and Christen threw their shocked faces on.
"No, she can't move on that quick she was literally crying over you 1 hour ago." Christen said as a tear ran down my face.
"Don't assume, lets all just go inside and see what there doing." Tobin said as she brought out her keys to open her front door.
Please don't.
AJ's Pov
"Olivia I'm sorry you had to find out this way." I say to as I gave her a cup of water and some Advil.
